Bite the bullet
Old tables, and other broken items, however beloved, should make room for new and better
Dear Sam,
My small 34-inch dining table has broken. I’ve had the table forever, I think I was leaning on it and literally a chunk broke off and some sawdust crumbled to the floor! The top was wood and the base black. It was perfect, but I don’t know if it’s worth repairing.
I’ve looked at a few websites, but all the tables look like they would be fine in my place. I really want to know which tables you think are top shelf. I am living in my “forever” condo. I have a full dining table, which I use when I have company. The small one in my kitchen is where I spend all my time and have breakfast in the morning because the light is great.
The other reason I’m writing is because on your show you said high-top tables are not appropriate in homes — I had been debating a cleanlined one. I’m willing to spend more if the table will last a long time, but obviously would love a deal. Please help, CJ Dear CJ,
Sounds like you got plenty of use out of your table. Unfortunately, particleboard will sometimes break and crumble at your feet. And, as my father said to me when my 13-year-old car just died on the road after having lost a part, “Honey, it didn’t owe you anything”. I never could identify that part. But I know how it feels to become attached to that perfect thing. But don’t have it repaired. It’s particleboard and will likely break again.
Regarding high-top tables, I say a lot of stuff on TV. Sometimes I talk about general rules, but oftentimes what I’m saying is relative to that specific space. But yes, as far as high-top tables go, I’m not a fan, unless you want to feel like you are dining in a food court or a pub. That said, if your condo had a high window where you could look out, a high-top table would work. If you have large floor-toceiling windows, however, as many condos do, then go with a standard 30-inch-high table.
You didn’t mention anything about your existing chairs. All the tables I’ve selected here are classics and my “top-shelf ” picks. I love these tables because they will work with many different chair styles, from upholstered or wood to moulded plastic or industrial steel. Of course, as everyone says on television: Forget about matched sets and don’t be afraid to mix and match.
Happy (small) dining table shopping!
Sam