National Post

ONLY WAY TO QUIET NEWTON IS TO BEAT HIM.

But Newton still faces criticism other QBs don’t

- Cam Cole

So you don’t like Cam Newton? Take a number. Bet you are from the “when you get to the end zone, act like you’ve been there before” school — the famous admonition variously attributed to Bear Bryant, Vince Lombardi and Darrell Royal — and the Carolina Panthers quarterbac­k’s overthe- top celebratio­ns make you pine for the days of Bart Starr or Roger Staubach.

Of course, those were the days, before Doug Williams, before Warren Moon, before Steve McNair, when African-American players weren’t considered cerebral enough to be trusted with a responsi ble position l i ke NFL quarterbac­k.

Peyton Manning is the current avatar of the old school; his low-key acknowledg­ment after a touchdown most closel-lyy resembles the old stan dards of decorum — trot to the sideline, a few pats on the helmet, and he’s done — but his era is almost done, too.

Monday, which was Martin Luther King Day in the U.S ., was a reasonable occasion to at least ask the question: is it Newton’s behaviour or his colour, or a combinatio­n of the two, that make him the NFL’s most polarizing player, even as he strengthen­s the argument that he is this year’s league MVP?

If he were Joe Namath or Brett Favre, would you be more likely to write off his cockiness and just love the performanc­e?

You don’t have to buy it, but consider it.

It can’t be all about colour, because there’s Seattle’s Russell Wilson’s humbler example to lead the counterarg­ument.

But it’ s something… something about the way quarterbac­ks (white, in the mind’s eye) have always carried themselves, that seems to be at odds with the hyperactiv­e 26-year-old who leads the Panthers into next Sunday’s NFC final against the Arizona Cardinals.

Quarterbac­ks are supposed to wear a look of contained arrogance. Not too high, not too low, lest one’s teammates pick up a hint from the body language and lapse into despair, or celebrate too soon.

Newton breaks every one of those rules, with his primal screaming and leaping about, towel-waving and dancing.

It is exactly the kind of acting- out that prompted a scathing scouting report in Pro Football Weekly before the 2011 draft that said of the Auburn QB: “Very disingenuo­us … fake smile … selfish, me-first makeup. Always knows where the cameras are … enormous ego … sense of entitlemen­t that continuall­y invites trouble … does not command respect from teammates … will struggle to win a locker room. Lacks accountabi­lity, focus and trustworth­iness … is not punctual, seeks shortcuts and sets a bad example … Not dependable.”

Evidently, someone judged a book by its cover. White author, black athlete, by the way. Probably a coincidenc­e.

Despite being mentored by Moon in the leadup to his pro day prior to the 2011 draft — guided by the Hall of Famer on everything from clothes to preparatio­n to the added expectatio­ns that would be on him because he was African- American — Newton’s personalit­y could never come within a mile of Moon’s old-soul maturity.

He displays every emotion openly, and when opponents are driven to distractio­n by his antics, says: “If you don’t like it, keep me out of the end zone.”

In a league where there’s always someone bigger and badder who would love to knock your head off, that takes some serious confidence.

But the adage that applies here is: it ain’t bragging if you back it up. And Newton’s Panthers are 16-1 after Sunday’s 31-24 playoff win over Wilson and the Seahawks, which was actually a blowout disguised as a thriller.

The magnitude of the beating they laid on the Seahawks in that 31- 0 first half was less about Seattle not being ready to play than it was a demonstrat­ion of just how good Carolina could be. And Newton was, is, driving that bus.

If you don’t like it, at least respect it.

The sideshow, mind you, is dangerous because Newton is, in his own way, blazing a fresh trail for black quarterbac­ks, one that has gone more than a little bit cold since Moon and McNair and Donovan McNabb.

A good many highly touted African American QBs have either fired and fallen back ( Daunte Culpepper, Kordell Stewart, Michael Vick, Byron Leftwich), or barely fired at all ( Vince Young, Tarvaris Jackson, Ja-Marcus Russell, Geno Smith, Robert Griffin III).

Part of that may be because coaches give up on them earlier than they might with a white QB, but part has been simple underachie­vement, and NFL clubs that spend high draft picks on quarterbac­ks who don’t pan out will start questionin­g why, and may be tempted to look at race.

Newton and Russell Wilson, then, carry a great many hopes with them each time they suit up.

Only one of them — a big, ebullient, six- foot- five, 245- pound specimen with a big arm and a fine grasp of the game — remains in the chase, against Carson Palmer, and perhaps then either Peyton Manning or Tom Brady.

Lots of people would love to see any one of them wipe that perfectly even, self-satisfied smile off Cam Newton’s face.

But they might want to prepare for disappoint­ment.

 ??  ??
 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada