National Post (Latest Edition)

Immigratio­n officer’s letter ‘insulting’

- TereSA Wright

OTTAWA • A letter from a Canadian immigratio­n officer to a female applicant in Pakistan questions the legitimacy of her marriage, noting she is three years older than her husband, a Canadian citizen.

The immigratio­n officer based in London, England, told the woman her permanent residency applicatio­n appears suspect for a number of reasons.

“You and your sponsor (husband) do not appear well matched,” the letter states, a copy of which was provided to The Canadian Press.

“You are three years older than him, he comes from a town four hours from where you live and you are not related, so it is unclear to me why the match was made.”

It is unusual for Pakistani men to marry older women, especially if they are not related, the unnamed immigratio­n officer writes. The officer also notes their wedding guest list of 123 people was small compared to traditiona­l Pakistani weddings.

“This apparent deviation from the cultural norm raises concerns that your wedding may have taken place in order for you to gain permanent residence in Canada.”

The applicant’s husband is a Canadian citizen who has lived in Canada since 2005.

Federal NDP immigratio­n critic Jenny Kwan says the letter is “offensive and insulting.”

She has asked Immigratio­n Minister Ahmed Hussen to look into what she calls a systemic problem with the way Hussen’s department is treating applicatio­ns under the spousal sponsorshi­p program.

“To me, it’s completely inappropri­ate and I think it’s offensive and insulting,” Kwan said.

“I would like for the government to look at the systemic issue of this letter and why such letters are being sent out through those spousal sponsorshi­p applicatio­ns.”

Kwan said she followed up with the department, only to find letters with such language are routinely sent to spousal sponsorshi­p applicants from Pakistan to “’tease out a response.”’

“Who are they to judge whether or not that marriage is well-matched?” Kwan said.

“It’s one thing to say, ‘I do not believe in the authentici­ty of this marriage,’ it’s another to make a judgment on the quality of the marriage ... I find that offensive.”

Kwan raised the issue in question period this week and again with Hussen during a Commons committee meeting Thursday, asking for the government to review its treatment of spousal applicants.

Prime Minister Justin Trudeau defended the program during question period, saying he was pleased his government has reduced a backlog of applicatio­ns under spousal sponsorshi­p and has also reduced waiting times from two years to 12 months.

“We also know there is more to do,” Trudeau said.

Improvemen­ts to the program have been made, and scrutinizi­ng spousal sponsorshi­p applicatio­ns is an important part of the work of his department, Hussen added.

“Our department continues to uphold measures to safeguard against marriage fraud and other program integrity risks.”

Indeed, it’s not uncommon for the immigratio­n minister to become involved in cases involving spousal sponsorshi­p that go before the courts.

Last week, a Federal Court judge rejected a judicial review applicatio­n from Hussen’s office in a spousal case that was initially rejected and then won on appeal.

WHO ARE THEY TO JUDGE WHETHER OR NOT THAT MARRIAGE IS WELLMATCHE­D?

 ?? JUSTIN TANG /THE CANADIAN PRESS FILES ?? NDP MP and immigratio­n critic Jenny Kwan has responded to a letter from a Canadian immigratio­n official in London that questioned a Pakistani woman’s suitabilit­y with her husband.
JUSTIN TANG /THE CANADIAN PRESS FILES NDP MP and immigratio­n critic Jenny Kwan has responded to a letter from a Canadian immigratio­n official in London that questioned a Pakistani woman’s suitabilit­y with her husband.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada