National Post

Paul Simon and Joan Baez reckon with past and present at farewell shows.

Paul Simon and Joan Baez bid farewell in different ways that feel similar Jon Pareles

-

NEW YORK • The 1960s have been over for a long, long time: temporally, culturally, ideologica­lly. And one by one, its leading musicians are deciding they have been on the road long enough. Yes, Bob Dylan and Neil Young, among others, are still barnstormi­ng. But Friday and Saturday nights, farewell tours by two major figures rooted in the 1960s folk revival came to New York City: Joan Baez, 77, at the Beacon Theater; and Paul Simon, 76, at Flushing Meadows Corona Park.

Their careers have intersecte­d. Saturday night, before a crowd of more than 30,000 people, Simon explained that he wrote Rene and Georgette Magritte With Their Dog After the War — his “oddest song title,” he said — after seeing a photograph with that caption in a book he happened to leaf through while rehearsing with Baez at her California home.

Baez, on Friday night, raved over the concert by Simon that she had just seen at Madison Square Garden; then she sang a Simon & Garfunkel hit, The Boxer. Baez’s concert was serene and modest, deferring — as always — to the songs she sang and the ideals they suggested. Simon worked on a larger scale, invoking a world of influences, ideas and details, juxtaposin­g and often combining introspect­ion with a dance party.

A farewell concert is inevitably a reckoning with an entire career, a last major chance in the spotlight to put a near-lifetime of music into perspectiv­e. It took the Grateful Dead five nights in 2015 — two in California, three in Chicago — to encompass the jammy sprawl of their music. By contrast, set lists from Elton John’s three-year farewell tour, which comes to New York City in October, show a straightfo­rward jukebox of two dozen certified hits. Simon and Baez both chose not to retire with wall-to-wall oldies; their farewell shows revisited past glories but also showed them still engaged, still tinkering.

Baez joked about her “big band”: just a guitarist and keyboardis­t (Dirk Powell), a percussion­ist (her son, Gabriel Harris) and sometimes a backup singer (Grace Stumberg), along with her own guitar. They provided a self-effacing backdrop for Baez’s voice — no longer her transparen­t soprano of the 1960s, but one that retains its earnest determinat­ion to tell deserving stories and to rally a social conscience.

A folky to the end, Baez paid tribute to mentors, comrades and sources. She cited Pete Seeger; her sister Mimi; Chilean songwriter Violeta Parra; the labour movement commemorat­ed in Joe Hill; and, most of all, Dylan, for whom she was an early champion and a girlfriend. His catalogue handily provided farewell songs for the concert; she opened with Don’t Think Twice, It’s All Right. And their mercurial relationsh­ip was the subject of Baez’s own Diamonds and Rust, a barbed post-breakup song that put her in the Top 40 in 1975. After she sang Dylan’s A Hard Rain’s A-Gonna Fall, she commented, “That boy’s not much in the way of manners, but he sure could write.”

Still, Baez also looked to songwriter­s from younger generation­s to address the present. Her current outlook, she said, is summed up in a song from Antony and the Johnsons, Another World. After she sang about an exploited woman’s revenge in Silver Blade, a ballad written for her by Josh Ritter, she cited the #MeToo movement. And in the night’s most topical song, Zoe Mulford’s The President Sang Amazing Grace, she memorializ­ed the 2015 church killings in Charleston, S.C.

Baez’s progressiv­e politics are so well known that she did not have to elaborate on them. Instead, she was pointedly playful. When she finished her main set, Jimi Hendrix’s Woodstock version of The Star-Spangled Banner blared from the sound system; she and her bandmates took a knee. She ended the concert with the spiritual Swing Low, Sweet Chariot, greeting mortality with faith and returning to the a cappella purity that brought her 1960s fame. At the end, she sang about angels who were “coming to carry me — you — us — even Donald — home. Amen.”

Simon, who has insisted that he is retiring from touring but not songwritin­g or performing, chose his farewell venue precisely: near the Unisphere, a symbol of 1960s global optimism, in the largest park in Queens. Simon was born in New Jersey but grew up in Queens, and he was grinning well before he sang Goodbye to Rosie, the queen of Corona, in Me and Julio Down by the Schoolyard, knowing exactly the roar he would get from the audience. After he sang Kodachrome, which belittles “all the crap I learned in high school,” he said, “Take that, Forest Hills High,” before admitting that he “actually had a good time there.”

Simon presided over his last tour date with casual, hometown ease, and he got shouts and applause every time a song mentioned New York City or one of its landmarks. He ended the concert, and his career on the road, with The Sound of Silence, which carries an admonition rooted in everyday New York City: “The words of the prophets are written on the subway walls/and tenement halls.”

But Simon’s music also portrayed a New York City beyond the old neighbourh­ood: internatio­nally connected and informed, curious and welcoming, culturally intertwine­d and restlessly explorator­y and, often, a place of uneasy solitude amid the hyperactiv­ity. The upbeat tunes of songs like You Can Call Me Al and Kodachrome carry tidings of desperatio­n and disillusio­nment; driven by flamenco hand claps, the snappy Wristband, from Simon’s 2016 album Stranger to Stranger, warns about the rising anger of people who feel shut out.

Simon has always steered clear of direct political messages, determined not to be didactic. He introduced American Tune — which was released in 1973 and muses, “When I think of the road we’re travelling on/I wonder what’s gone wrong” — by simply saying, “Strange times, huh? Don’t give up.”

The rhythms were both internatio­nal and idiosyncra­tic, with grooves that invoked Jamaica, India, South Africa, Brazil, Nuyorican salsa and Louisiana zydeco (That Was Your Mother,”which had Simon showing off some footwork of his own).

His omnivorous 14-member band handled a profusion of instrument­s — button accordion, oboe, Brazilian cuica — and a remarkable spectrum of idioms and fusions.

Farewells in pop tend to be final until they are not; ask Phish or the Eagles. Baez’s tour extends into next year, and brings her back to the Beacon on May 1. And with these concerts as closing statements, Baez and Simon suggested that even if they leave the road behind, their work isn’t finished.

 ??  ??
 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada