Bordellos feel the burn
Competition from the web is hurting Nevada’s brothels, B8
In a dim parlour furnished with red velvet couches and a stripper pole, Brooke Taylor is having a sale on herself.
“I offer a lot more specials and discounts and incentives for people to come in to see me,” said Taylor, 32, a brunette prostitute in a short, green dress at the Moonlite Bunny Ranch outside Carson City, Nev. “People are looking for deals.”
Nevada’s legal brothels, which took root in the mid1800s silver-mining boom, are dwindling, down to about 19 from roughly 36 in 1985, according to George Flint, an industry lobbyist. Many have been the highest-profile businesses in their sparsely populated regions, and their decline hurts already-stretched county budgets.
The state’s flagging economy, decreased patronage by truckers squeezed by fuel costs and growing use of the Internet to arrange liaisons are to blame, managers say.
“A lot of our clients don’t have the discretionary income they had six years ago, five years ago,” said Susan Austin, 63, the madam of the Mustang Ranch in Sparks, Nev.
Recent years have not been kind to Nevada. The 18-month recession that began in December 2007 still holds a grip on the state. It had America’s highest unemployment rate in July, 9.5 per cent, compared with 7.4 per cent nationwide, according to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. Since the last quarter of 2007, the state’s economic health has declined 46 per cent, according to the Bloomberg Economic Evaluation of States.
Most brothels are in rural areas with few people and employers. The brothels pay little to the state, sending most of their fees and tax payments to the counties.
In Lyon County, where the largest private employers are an Amazon.com Inc. distribution centre and a Wal-Mart Stores Inc. outlet, total revenue fell from $33 million US in fiscal 2009 to $29 million in 2012, according to Josh Foli, its comptroller.
In the fiscal year ended June 30, Lyon’s four brothels paid it $369,600 in business-licensing fees and $17,800 from work permits for the prostitutes, Foli said. The brothels also pay room and property taxes to the county, along with sales tax to the state on merchandise, including T-shirts.
Then there’s the main transaction: Visitors select from a lineup of women, negotiate a price and pay a cashier in advance. The women, independent contractors, say they typically give half to the house. Dennis Hof, owner of the Moonlite Bunny Ranch, said his customers spend $200 to $600 on average.
Austin said the Mustang Ranch is seeing fewer clients than five years ago.
“They’re getting less services because they’re paying less, but they’re still seeing their favourite ladies,” Austin said. “It’s like anything: When the economy takes a dive, you just live with less frills.”
Some say the downturn is overdue.
“Legal prostitution creates a cultural acceptance,” said Melissa Farley, executive director of Prostitution Research & Education, a San Franciscobased group that fights the sex trade. “The evidence tells us prostitution is profoundly harmful.”
The decline of the bordellos threatens an emblematic industry in a state that, since gangster Bugsy Siegel envisioned Las Vegas’s casinos in the 1940s, has cultivated a global reputation as a sinner’s paradise of gambling and louche delights.
The houses were woven into the fabric of the American West in the days of the pioneers, said Barb Brents, a sociology professor at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas. While some states banned them, Nevada left the question to local governments in counties with fewer than 700,000 residents. Ten of the state’s 17 counties allow them.
“They don’t bother anybody,” Brents said. “Brothels operate on an idea that men are a certain way and women are a certain way and there’s a need for these services.”
Prostitution is shifting online, said Scott Peppet, who teaches law at the University of Colorado, Boulder, and writes about technology and markets. “A brothel is an intermediary,” Peppet said. “It’s pulling together women so it’s easy for buyers to find them.” That role is now being filled by the Internet, he said.
Craigslist, the free online classified-advertising site, eliminated its adult-services section in 2010 in response to pressure from state attorneys general. Many ads shifted to closely held Backpage.com.
In Las Vegas, the state’s largest city and one where prostitution is outlawed, women offer themselves online as “escorts.” Backpage.com carried more than 500 advertisements for Las Vegas on Aug. 25 alone. In 2012, the city’s “vice enforcement/arrests” rose 67 per cent to 8,908 from the year before, according to a 2012 annual police department report.