Canadian dollar could throw wrench into rate cuts
Conditions are shaping up for the Bank of Canada to start cutting interest rates, but will our currency throw a wrench in the works?
Expectations that Canada’s central bank will move before the United States Federal Reserve has put pressure on the loonie, which has dropped 1.7 per cent against a strong U.S. dollar.
The Canadian dollar fell again yesterday after weaker retail sales data added to the case for rate cuts.
As the gap between the two central banks’ policy paths widens, the loonie’s outlook dims.
While the Bank of Canada is expected to cut rates in June or July, predictions for the Fed’s first cut have been pushed back to December, with some questioning whether it will cut at all this year.
The Bank of Canada is expected to trim 100 to 125 basis points off its 5 per cent rate this year; the Fed only 25 bps.
How big this gap gets is a key question for the Canadian dollar.
Bofa Global Research has cut its outlook for the currency on signs the divergence will be wider than previously expected.
It now forecasts the Canadian dollar will fall to 72.99 US cents in the second quarter of this year, and reach 75.75 US cents by the end of 2025, down from its earlier forecast of 76.9 US cents.
A weaker Canadian dollar raises the risks of inflation as goods become more expensive to import. Bofa estimates that each big drop in the Canadian dollar could add 15 bps to the consumer price index. If the gap between the two central banks grows wide enough to push the loonie down to 69 US cents it could hike inflation by a full percentage point, they said.
“For now, we believe the BOC would likely tolerate some short-term loonie weakness as it looks to embark on the rate cutting cycle,” said Bofa strategist Howard Du and economist Carlos Capistran.
“But should the BOC rate cuts lead to sharp CAD selloff or a prolonged period of CAD downtrend, the FX market would likely start to become concerned with renewed inflation risks for Canada and the consequences a strong USD imposes on rest of the world including Canada.”
This could raise concerns about how deeply the Bank of Canada can cut or whether policy makers will be forced to pause to allow the Fed to catch up.
Governor Tiff Macklem said at the bank’s last decision on April 10 that policy makers were watching the currency.
“If the Canadian dollar does move, that’s something that we’ll take into account in terms of our outlook,” he told reporters.
The Bank of Canada has intervened before, said the Bofa researchers. After the 1997 Asia financial crisis the loonie was hammered by a strong American dollar and falling oil prices. In August to September of 1998 Canada’s central bank raised its policy rate by 100 bps and conducted direct intervention in the FX market.
“The current macro backdrop is still far from a crisis level and risk of BOC intervention is low,” said Du and Capistran.
“But should the CAD see excessive weakness after the BOC rate cutting cycle starts, this is a risk that market should not ignore, in our view.”
Not all economists agree. Nathan Janzen, assistant chief economist at the Royal Bank of Canada, argues that currencies have not “moved the needle” on inflation in the past.
More than half of Canadian consumer spending is on services and goods are imported from more sources than the United States. Canada’s weaker economy also makes it harder for businesses to pass on price increases.
Bank of Montreal senior economist Sal Guatieri, however, does think the Canadian dollar could become an issue for the central bank.
“So far, the weak loonie is adding welcomed support to the economy without threatening prices stability. But that could change if it takes a further swan dive,” he said.