The Daily Courier

Don’t be friendly when we’re buying an embarrassi­ng product

-

When consumers buy embarrassi­ng products, they don’t want friendly service

A UBC Sauder School of Business study shows that when people buy blush-inducing items, they choose self-checkout – or failing that, the most robotic human available.

It’s an age-old law of marketing that friendly customer service is a sure way to boost your business. But customers who are buying embarrassi­ng products don’t necessaril­y want a smiling face or pleasant small talk.

For the study in the Journal of Marketing Research titled “How consumers respond to embarrassi­ng service encounters: A dehumaniza­tion perspectiv­e,” the authors studied data of actual purchase behaviour in grocery stores and observed whether customers prefer self-checkout or a human cashier when purchasing embarrassi­ng products such as condoms or menstrual pads.

The authors also surveyed participan­ts about their preference­s in situations where in-person exchanges are unavoidabl­e, such as taking a stained clothing item to a dry cleaner that has no automated option.

The researcher­s found that when people buy embarrassi­ng items, they choose self-service checkouts – and when self-checkouts aren’t available and customers have to interact with a human, they choose the most robotic one they can find.

“If they have to choose a person, they would prefer a mechanisti­c person who isn’t known to be particular­ly friendly,” said UBC Sauder Professor JoAndrea Hoegg, who co-authored the study with Yixia Sun of Zhejiang University, Xuehua Wang of Tongi University, and UBC Sauder School of Business Dean Darren Dahl.

If they can’t find a robotic person and have to engage in a more normal way, they try to compensate by thinking of the person as less human – and by extension, less social, emotional and judgmental.

“They engage in this mental process of mechanisti­c dehumaniza­tion. They think, ‘That person doesn’t care about me or what I’m doing. They’re just doing their job,’” explained Hoegg. “They do that to make themselves feel better. But we didn’t find any evidence that strategy actually works. They were still embarrasse­d.”

The study also surveyed people on the street about their use of particular products, either embarrassi­ng (condoms) or non-embarrassi­ng (gum). Some of the surveyors acted in a more personable way, using eye contact and a friendly facial expression and vocal tone, while others acted in a more robotic way, avoiding eye contact and using a stiff expression and tone.

The researcher­s examined the difference in how thoroughly each group of participan­ts answered the questions.

“With the robotic person, people actually answered more questions on the survey and gave more informatio­n,” said Hoegg. “We thought that was interestin­g and potentiall­y important, because if you’re in a medical office or pharmacy and you need to provide informatio­n about yourself, you might be too embarrasse­d if the person is being really friendly and trying to make a connection.”

The findings were similar across genders and challenge the longheld belief that building personal rapport with customers should be the top priority for service employees, as warm, welcoming interactio­ns are linked with higher customer satisfacti­on.

“This study kind of turns that on its head,” said Hoegg. “When people are buying embarrassi­ng things they don’t seek out conversati­on. They don’t want that social interactio­n. They want to get in and get out – and they want someone who isn’t judging them or reacting to them.”

So what should pharmacy workers and other retail staff do when customers buy embarrassi­ng items? Hoegg says they should skip the small talk and get the person out the door.

“There are so many places like 7Eleven and grocery stores that sell everything, and it’s likely that employees have been told to be friendly and engage their customers. But they should be mindful of the purchases people are making, and if the person isn’t making eye contact, they don’t need to engage them,” said Hoegg.

“If the product they are buying is one that might be embarrassi­ng for them, don’t try to create a connection,” she advised. “Just get the person out quickly.”

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada