The Hamilton Spectator

Ford and friends showing us who they are really serving


The Greenbelt has been carved up; the conservati­on authoritie­s gutted; wetlands opened for paving; municipal government­s financiall­y hamstrung; and massive boundary expansions imposed onto Hamilton and Halton foodlands. There have been over 80 rallies across the province.

The tide of anger at Premier Doug Ford is understand­able, but probably misdirecte­d. It mistakenly assumes that voters rule, not corporatio­ns.

The protests have little effect, since the premier and his Progressiv­e Conservati­ves clearly reject basic democratic principles. They have even overturned majority rule in city councils with their “strong mayor” legislatio­n. Now what?

First, follow the money. Virtually everything the Conservati­ves have forced through in the last three months has had one obvious objective — slashing growth fees and environmen­tal rules to benefit billionair­e land speculator­s and greenfield developmen­t corporatio­ns. These are obviously the real “governors” in Ontario.

With no democratic options left for the public, shaming and blocking these puppet masters is an appropriat­e path forward. Direct action to defend farmland and wetlands is probably the only way left to prevent the further destructio­n of our environmen­t and climate.

The huge political influence of big developers has been obvious in Hamilton for decades. They have consistent­ly been the overwhelmi­ng source of campaign donations. But residents said enough and stood up to this in 2021. More than 16,000 replied to a city-run survey and over 90 per cent chose the option of no boundary expansion — at least 87 per cent in every ward.

City council then voted 13-3 for that option. Two of the three sprawl supporters didn’t even dare run again in last October’s elections, and the third was soundly defeated despite having been a councillor for nearly three decades.

No one was elected on a platform of expanding the urban area onto more farmland.

But that was just the appearance of democracy. The big developers simply turned to their PC puppets in Queen’s Park who imposed a 2,185-hectare expansion onto local foodlands and wetlands plus 769 hectares of the formerly permanentl­y protected Greenbelt.

Both city voters and councillor­s were treated as irrelevant. Officially, the excuse is cities aren’t mentioned in the constituti­on so are deemed “children of the province.” Hamilton has more residents than each of two Canadian provinces; Toronto more than five.

Conservati­ves work overtime to make voting irrelevant, especially for city councils.

Two decades ago there were 59 elected officials in Hamilton — about one per 8,300 residents. Forced amalgamati­on by a PC government slashed that to 16, and with 100,000 more people we now have one representa­tive per 36,000 residents.

Higher population­s per councillor requires more money to get elected so more dependence on rich donors. It also means much more work per councillor, and therefore much less time to respond to resident concerns.

Even then their decisions are overrun by the province whose legislatio­n now comes in omnibus bills to avoid debate — Bill 23 changed nine separate previous acts and ran to hundreds of pages.

Nor is democracy inside Queen’s Park, not even a hint that an MPP could vote against the party dictatorsh­ip. It is so locked up that media don’t even bother to report on the views of individual members.

None of what the PC government has done was included in their June election platform.

Indeed, their tactics then were say as little as possible about their plans, keep Ford under wraps, and direct their nominees to avoid all-candidate meetings. The low turnout was quite intentiona­l. And combined with a broken electoral system, just 18 per cent of eligible voters imposed a majority PC government.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada