Nationals confident Scherzer will ace post-season test
WASHINGTON—Based on what everyone says about Washington Nationals righty Max Scherzer, he seems like an obvious choice to start the NL wildcard game against Milwaukee.
Scherzer is, in the words of Brewers manager Craig Counsell, “probably going to the hall of fame.”
Brandon Woodruff, Counsell’s choice to start for visiting Milwaukee on Tuesday night, couldn’t wait to meet Scherzer at the all-star game and admires the three-time Cy Young Award winner because he has that “kind of fire inside of him a little bit.”
“We’re fortunate,” Nationals manager Dave Martinez said, “to have a Max Scherzer pitch in the wild-card game.”
Is it really that clear-cut? Martinez could have, instead, gone with Stephen Strasburg, who, unlike Scherzer (11-7, 2.92 ERA, 27 starts), was healthy all year and put up some of the best numbers of his career. Strasburg and rotation-mate Patrick Corbin will be available in the bullpen.
There’s also an elephant in the room: Scherzer’s post-season statistics.
It is unfashionable these days to even mention win-loss records when it comes to pitchers, but Scherzer’s teams — the Nationals and, before that, the Detroit Tigers — have not enjoyed much success with him on the mound in the playoffs of late.
Since a 2013 AL Division Series victory for Detroit against Oakland, Scherzer has made seven post-season appearances, in a mix of starting and relieving, and his teams are 0-7. Scherzer himself is 0-4 in that stretch, lowering his career record in the post-season from 4-1 to 4-5.
“Season’s on the line. I’ve pitched in these situations before, and it’s just crazy baseball. The intensity’s out of your mind,” said Scherzer, who took the loss in Washington’s most recent October flop, coming in during the fifth inning of a Game 5 home loss to the Chicago Cubs in a 2017 NLDS. “And you’ve got to go out there and be your best and just compete as hard as you can.”
The Nationals are 0-3 in winner-take-all post-season games, all at home. They’ve never advanced in four previous trips to the playoffs over the last eight years.
The Brewers, in contrast, made it to a Game 7 of the NCLS just a year ago.
Another disparity at play in a game that will determine who advances to face the NL West champion Los Angeles Dodgers starting Thursday: How they try to get 27 outs.
“We’re different. And I think playoff teams should be different,” Counsell said. “I think that’s cool.”
The Nationals rely heavily on their rotation, led by Scherzer, Strasburg and Corbin, who all ranked in the top 10 in the NL in ERA, strikeouts and opponents’ batting average. Their bullpen’s collective ERA, meanwhile, was the worst in the majors this season.
That is part of the reason Martinez says Strasburg and Corbin are available in relief.
“A game like tomorrow, you put roles aside, you put egos aside, and you go with your best guys,” closer Sean Doolittle said, “and those are our best guys.”