The Province

FIVE THINGS

B.C.’s ombudspers­on released a scathing report Thursday into the government’s wrongful firing of eight public health researcher­s in 2012, and the subsequent suicide of one of them. Here are five things to know about his report:

- — Rob Shaw

1 The researcher­s didn’t deserve to be fired

Ombudspers­on Jay Chalke reviewed more than four million documents and interviewe­d 130 people to make his conclusion. “The ministry did not have sufficient evidentiar­y basis to dismiss any of the employees for just cause,” he wrote. “We determined that none of the dismissed employees engaged in conduct sufficient to support their terminatio­ns.”

2 Though the scandal is politicall­y charged, there was no political interferen­ce

Chalke put Premier Christy Clark, Health Minister Terry Lake and Finance Minister Mike de Jong under oath for questionin­g and concluded that although they were aware of the case, they didn’t direct the civil service’s actions.“There was no political interferen­ce in the dismissals,” he wrote.

3 The whistleblo­wer who made the original allegation­s was wrong

The ministry official, named Alana James, alleged contractin­g irregulari­ties, conflicts of interest and other breaches. “The complainan­t was uninformed and her assertions were mostly wrong,” wrote Chalke. That didn’t stop the unfounded accusation­s from snowballin­g into an unfair and one-sided government investigat­ion, said Chalke.

4 It was improper for government to claim the fired researcher­s were under police investigat­ion

Not only because it was unfair to the researcher­s, but also because it was wrong, wrote Chalke. “The RCMP was not investigat­ing and never did,” he wrote.

5 The fired researcher­s deserve compensati­on

Chalke recommende­d grievance payments of up to $125,000 a person, formal apologies and $500,000 to create a university scholarshi­p in memory of Roderick MacIsaac, the university student who was fired improperly and then killed himself. Government agreed Thursday to all the recommenda­tions.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada