Scientists and university clash over strawberries
FRESNO, California — Plant scientist Douglas Shaw spent his career toiling in the fields in California to grow the perfect strawberry, one that was plump and bright red yet remained sweet even after the long trip to grocery store.
When the professor retired from the University of California at Davis and set up his own strawberry-breeding business, though, he found himself in a legal jam.
In a case set for hearing in federal court this month, the university is suing Shaw and his scientific partner, saying they stole the school’s intellectual property by taking some of the fruits of their research with them.
The two scientists claim in a $45-million US lawsuit of their own that the university has unfairly kept some of their work locked in a freezer and is depriving the world of a better strawberry.
Some farmers in the United States’ No. 1 strawberry-growing state fear the battle is going to stymie research and cause them to lose their competitive edge. Last year, California produced 1.6 tons of strawberries valued at about $2 billion, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture.
“It doesn’t do anybody any good for the university to keep these strawberry plants in a box,” said Rick McKnight, a lawyer for the two former professors. “This is hurting the California strawberry industry in a major way.”
Shaw, 63, headed the university’s lucrative strawberry breeding program for more than two decades alongside fellow plant biologist Kirk Larson. Most of California’s strawberry farmers grow plants the two developed.
The two men developed 24 new varieties. They created strawberries that were more pest- and disease-resistant, more durable during long-distance travel, or capable of growing during the shorter daylight in spring and fall.
The partners say their work netted the university $100 million in royalties. How much they themselves made at UC Davis is unclear, but they say they contributed more than $9 million of their own royalties toward the university’s breeding program.
They retired from the university in 2014 and launched California Berry Cultivars. The company set out to develop new varieties of strawberries and supply them to the growers and nurseries that are partners in the business.
The university accuses the researchers of patent infringement and violating an oath they signed not to enrich themselves by taking or acquiring plants, seeds and other biological material and continuing their research using descendants of plants they developed at UC Davis.
The scientists say they own the intellectual property at issue, and they accuse the university of locking up some of their plants and destroying hundreds of others, wiping out years of research.
Strawberry growers want a quick resolution. “Costly litigation is such a waste when there are avenues for multi-benefit collaboration,” said A.G. Kawamura, a strawberry farmer, former California agriculture secretary and part owner of California Berry Cultivars. “Our future as California strawberry growers is at stake.”