Study: Black medical students face hurdles to career in surgery
Few Black medical students are pursuing careers as surgeons in Canada due to lack of mentorship, problematic admission criteria and racist microaggressions during training, among other factors, a study published Tuesday says.
That’s a problem not only because it shows inequitable access to surgical training, but also because a diverse workforce is essential for good patient care, researchers from St. Michael’s Hospital and the University of Toronto medical school say.
“To improve patient satisfaction and the quality of care patients receive, the surgical workforce must reflect the variety of patients for which they provide care,” said the study published in the Journal of the American College of Surgeons.
Senior author Dr. Jory Simpson, chief of general surgery at St. Michael’s Hospital, said he wanted to find out what barriers were causing “an underrepresentation of Black surgeons in Canada” so that medical schools and hospitals could address them.
“Not everybody has the same opportunity to succeed right now,” Simpson said in an interview.
Researchers for the qualitative study, led by Black medical students Edgar Akuffo-Addo and Jaycie Dalson, interviewed 27 Black participants in medical schools across Canada, including 18 medical students and nine surgical residents.
A “common struggle” cited was “not really having Black mentors at all, because there are very few Black physicians and even fewer specifically in surgery,” said Dalson.
“So if you’re looking for that question of ‘what is it like to be a Black surgeon?’ … there’s not many people who can answer that question,” she said.
Black students are more likely to come from a lower socioeconomic background than white students, the study said, which in turn affects the connections Black students have to help guide them into and through medical school.
“Mentorship is extremely important early on in one’s medical career,” said Simpson, who is white.
“I had family friends that were surgeons and they kind of took me under their wing on like Day 1 of medical school and, you know, talked to me and mentored me and invited me to opportunities that other people may have not gotten.”
The lack of mentorship, as well as disparities in socioeconomic status, tied into another key barrier identified by the participants — an overemphasis on research experience when selecting medical students for surgical residencies.
“If I don’t have any mentor or don’t have the connection or the social capital, how can I find research projects?” AkuffoAddo said.
The study found that Black medical students were more likely to have experience with advocacy work than research.
“They’re really doing projects that are seeking to build communities that they come from, because historically, Black people have been marginalized, when it comes to health care,” said Akuffo-Addo.
“Once people get into medical school, they try their best to kind of help their local communities,” he said.
Black med students might spend their time doing things like “blood pressure screening, mentoring kids from underserved high schools, trying to kind of, you know, tell kids it’s possible to be Black and to also be a physician,” Akuffo-Addo said.
That type of work has been undervalued in the surgical residency selection process, Simpson said.
“If you look at the amount of time and commitment it takes to do strong advocacy work, it’s the same amount as it would to do research. And one could argue that the impact is much higher,” he said.
Once Black students get into surgical residencies, they often feel excluded or face racist comments or microaggressions, the study said.
“As a Black surgical resident, you are one of either a few or the only one. The lack of belonging and the isolation that comes with it can impact your psychological well-being,” one of the study’s participants said.
The study authors did not disclose the names of the participants “due to privacy and ethical restrictions.”
“People didn’t expect somebody who looks like me to be in an OR,” another participant said.
“I tried to rationalize that maybe it’s just because they don’t know me, or they’ve never seen me before … in the back of my mind I did wonder if this would this be the same for a white male medical student.
I was clearly dressed appropriately to be in the OR, in my scrubs etc.”
Another study participant described experiencing “overpolicing” by nurses and other staff compared with how their white colleagues were treated.
Racism from patients was another issue raised by participants, including an instance where a patient made a racist comment about Arabs “and my staff [supervisor] laughed it off.”
The authors hope that medical schools across Canada will use their findings to “offer a safe space for Black students and trainees to access and complete surgical training successfully.”
“We want to support Black students as they go through [medical school] so they get into the specialties that they want,” said Dalson.
“Diversity is so important so we have everybody’s face at the table when we’re making medical decisions.”