Toronto Star

Try Khadr in Canada

TERROR CHARGES A Canadian is being denied fairness, justice, basis rights and has no standing under Geneva Convention

-

Re U. S. charges Omar Khadr with murder, aiding enemy Nov. 8. Omar Khadr has been denied the most basic of legal rights entrenched in our Canadian Constituti­on. Despite being charged with terrorist- related offences in the United States, he is still a Canadian. And as such, he should be entitled to at least the basic rights and freedoms every Canadian has. Not only has he been denied basic legal pre-trial rights, allegation­s of torture ( which our own Canadian Security and Intelligen­ce Service is alleged to have participat­ed in) are at hand. Despite the fact that torture is not unheard of for detain- ees in Guantanamo Bay, I have to repeat that Khadr is a Canadian. A Canadian is being tortured in Guantanamo Bay. A Canadian is being denied fairness, justice and basic rights. A Canadian is being denied standing under the Geneva Convention. He is being denied standing as a human being, a Canadian.

I am sure there are countless pre- trial constituti­onal rights which have not been granted to Khadr. After all, having no standing under the Geneva Convention will deprive you of any protection from internatio­nal laws and the protection afforded by the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms is only reserved for those to whom Canadian laws are being applied. The reality is that the laws being applied in the Khadr’s case are the same laws that will be applied at his trial. They were created by and belong to U.S. president George W. Bush. They are not internatio­nal or Canadian or even American, for that matter. They are laws which were arbitraril­y made up to serve Bush’s “ war on terror.” These laws are applied in courts which sacrifice justice for conviction­s and fairness for what they term “ national security.” Here is Canada’s chance to take a stand. This is Prime Minister Paul Martin’s chance to ask for justice on behalf of a country which believes in it. Let’s set the precedent for justice and fairness for Canadians detained abroad.

Let Khadr be tried and judged in Canada, a democracy. Mariana Alves, Mississaug­a

 ?? RICK EGLINTON/STAR FILE PHOTO ?? Omar Khadr’s mother Maha Elsamnah, right, and his grandmothe­r Fatmah Elsamnah hold a press conference earlier this year.
RICK EGLINTON/STAR FILE PHOTO Omar Khadr’s mother Maha Elsamnah, right, and his grandmothe­r Fatmah Elsamnah hold a press conference earlier this year.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada