Harper opts for vengeance rather than crime prevention
The Harper government unveiled a new bill on Wednesday that will force judges and parole officers to send cop killers, terrorists and brutal murderers to prison for life with no hope of release — a redundant move that will be both a rights and public-safety disaster.
Canada can already keep murderers and dangerous offenders in prison forever without new laws to force the hand of justice professionals. The killer of the three RCMP officers slain in Moncton was sentenced to life with a minimum of 75 years — what more do we need?
The pending legislation is simply the latest in a string of moves to turn the justice system into a machine for pure vengeance. While perhaps cathartic, vengeance is a misspent emotion — burning the cash that should be invested in what actually prevents violence and keeps front-line cops and communities safe.
For the past 30 years, U.S. politicians tried to outwit the good sense of courts and took their already infamous punitive policies to extremes unknown on the planet. In 1970, there were 500,000 Americans behind bars, today there are 2.2 million. As a rate proportionate to population, the U.S. locks up seven times more people than Canada.
Equipped with such a formidable vengeance machine, U.S. rates of homicide are still three times ours and four of its cities are among the 50 most violent in the world. And this machine is hungry, gobbling up the biggest proportion of tax revenues in the western world.
Our own vengeance crisis has been brewing: fighting crime by using life sentences comes with a cost — even adding 1,000 prisoners at $100,000 a year for 30 years is $3 billion. Living in an age with considerable knowledge about what does prevent violence and enhance public safety, this money could be better spent on front-line policing and community crime prevention.
Ironically, the U.S. Department of Justice shares solutions on what is aptly called crimesolutions.gov. Among the 327 programs on this website, it has identified 78 “effective” solutions, more than half of which tackle the social roots of crime — such as helping parents with kids difficult for them to manage, mentoring at-risk kids to help them succeed, or teaching life skills in schools to reduce adolescent abuse of alcohol and drugs.
A report issued by the Council of Canadian Academies last December lamented the lack of research on public safety in Canada. Despite this, two Canadian programs beat the odds to have been recognized by the U.S. Department of Justice. One is named 4th R because it teaches health relationships to teenagers in school and so reduces sexual assault and bullying. Another is named SNAP because it teaches at-risk kids to stop and plan to avoid being violent.
In addition, a network of cities co-ordinated through Montreal and Waterloo Region have been pioneering the Canadian way to bring social agencies and police together to tackle the roots of violence. Following the trailblazing work of former Prince Albert, Sask., police chief Dale McFee (now the province’s deputy minister of corrections and policing), several Ca- nadian police chiefs are experimenting with expanding police partnerships with health and education services. The next Toronto police chief must be up to speed on these approaches.
Finally, better training and safety equipment for police officers would of course be welcome. Alphonse MacNeil’s report into the Moncton tragedy, released in mid-January, shows an RCMP lacking in some of the essentials of modern policing — notably in the area of communications technology used to scramble officers in dangerous situations.
How much more effective could our police be with an investment in proper equipment, training and civilian oversight?
Putting our money into the front end of criminal justice equivalent to 10 per cent of what we are spending on pure vengeance, we would achieve a 50-per-cent reduction in violence over the next five to 10 years and would likely save hundreds of lives and billions of tax dollars each year. That is providing Canadians with public safety.
Vengeance is a misspent emotion, burning cash that should be invested in what actually prevents violence