Conquests boost extremists,
Insurgents are on front foot, dispelling sense of weakness
BEIRUT— Islamic State’s capture of the Iraqi city of Ramadi and the ancient Syrian town of Palmyra are no ordinary conquests.
After weeks of fighting, Ramadi’s fall on Sunday delivered the jihadist group control over a strategic highway linking Iraq and Syria, and a haul of weapons abandoned by Iraqi forces. Three days later, the Al Qaeda breakaway group overran Syrian government troops to seize Palmyra, home to the ruins of a 2,000-year-old city that was one of the most important cultural centres of the ancient world.
With the first anniversary of the declaration of its caliphate a month away, the victories put the militants on the front foot at a time when their leaders are seeking to dispel any sense of weakness after recent defeats. It now controls half of Syria’s territory and most of its oil and gas fields, according to the Syrian Observatory for Human Rights, a U.K.based group that monitors the conflict.
“The fact Islamic State is still on the offensive is important, and the timing is important,” said Charlie Winter, a researcher at the counterradicalization group Quilliam Foundation in London. Pushed into retreat, “it loses power and all the things that drive people to join it.”
The group’s supporters are already touting its latest feats, Winter said, posing the question on social media: “Last year it was Mosul, this year it’s Ramadi and where will it be next year?”
For Islamic State leader Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi and his commanders, it’s a propaganda coup to match their lightning advance across swaths of Syria and Iraq in June last year.
In Iraq, Ramadi’s fall prompted Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi to turn to Shiite militias, whose abuses elsewhere have fuelled enmity among Sunni tribes toward his government.
The fight to confront Islamic State is aimed at inflicting battlefield losses, countering its appeal to disaffected Muslims and restricting its finances. As war rages, territory under the group’s control comes and goes, said Kamran Bokhari, an adviser for Middle Eastern and South Asian affairs at Texas-based consulting firm Stratfor.
“If they lose an area, they retain the ability to push into somewhere else,” Bokhari said from Toronto. Still, although there’s “a big hype created in the media regarding Ramadi, on the battleground, it’s business as usual: a few kilometres this way or a few kilometres that way,” he said.
The group has lost more territory in Iraq than it has in Syria, according to Bokhari.
Peshmerga fighters have made advances against Islamic State in Kurdish-populated areas of Iraq’s Nineveh province, and the group has lost footholds in the eastern Diyala province. The recapture of Tikrit, on the main north-south highway between Baghdad and Mosul, by government forces marked a strategic blow for the jihadists.
In Syria, airstrikes by a U.S.-led coalition helped Kurdish forces repel its fighters from Kobani this year, and more recently from areas around Tal Tamr in Hasakah province. Yet it has made inroads in Deir Ezzour and eastern Homs in addition to capturing Palmyra.
Only two oil and gas fields, the Shaer and Rumeilan, are outside of the group’s control, according to the Syrian Observatory, which monitors the civil war through activists on the ground. Islamic State declared the Syrian city of Raqqa as the capital of a self-proclaimed caliphate announced at the end of June.
The group will probably retain control over its heartland, especially in Syria, for the medium term, risk analysis company Verisk Maplecroft said in a recent research note. It’s “especially well-entrenched in Iraq’s Sunni hinterland and eastern Syria, which collectively remains the core of the group’s territory,” it said.
Islamic State’s resilience is made possible by its diverse sources of income. After losing control of some oilfields, it relied more heavily on taxation and extortion.
It is also bolstered by an ability to sustain local services and its deftness in convincing Sunnis in Syria and in Iraq that they’d be worse off under Shiite governments.
Long-lasting solutions to Sunni grievances coupled with military victories are needed, and the U.S.-led alliance should do more to challenge Islamic State’s propaganda machine, Winter said.
“It is resisting very effectively the coalition campaign against it,” he said. “But I still think that with the right strategy, it could be a fairly transient entity.”