Toronto Star

Feds gently move back into temporary foreign worker quagmire

- Thomas Walkom

Justin Trudeau’s Liberals are tiptoeing back into the minefield that is Canada’s temporary foreign workers program.

They are doing so carefully. This month’s decision to relax the rules for seasonal industries wishing to hire cheap foreign labour was not publicly announced.

Instead, the informatio­n — that such industries will be able to hire unlimited numbers of temporary foreign workers for up to 180 days a year — seeped out through the media.

This particular goody was designed to appeal to fish-plant owners in Atlantic Canada who had been chafing under stricter rules put in place by the previous Conservati­ve government.

But it was also welcomed by hoteliers and restaurate­urs who operate seasonally.

According to press reports, resort owners in Banff, who might otherwise have been forced to hire unemployed Albertans at higher wages, were particular­ly pleased.

The unemployme­nt rate in Alberta is 7.9 per cent. In Atlantic Canada, it runs anywhere from 9.1 to 14.1 per cent.

You might ask why, if so many Canadians are out of work, the federal government is making it easier for employers to bring in cheap foreign temporary help.

You might ask how this contribute­s to Trudeau’s stated goal of strengthen­ing Canada’s middle class.

The answer, which isn’t very satisfacto­ry, is that much of Canada’s economy is built around low-wage labour.

Atlantic fish-plant owners, for instance, argue that they can’t compete internatio­nally unless they pay wages that are so low Canadians won’t accept them.

Instead, these owners import low-wage workers from countries like Thailand.

It’s the same argument made by Leamington-area tomato farmers who use cheap temporary workers from Mexico and the Caribbean to harvest their crop — a crop that, thanks to the ketchup wars between corporate giants Heinz and French’s, has become synonymous with Canadian nationalis­m.

Similarly, couples who want live-in nannies hire from countries like the Philippine­s. They do so not because foreigners are uniquely qualified to care for children but because they will accept lower pay than Canadians.

The expansion of the temporary foreign workers program into the manufactur­ing and services industries began more than a decade ago under Jean Chrétien’s Liberal government. It grew like wildfire under Stephen Harper’s Conservati­ves.

But faced with evidence that some businesses were firing Canadians in order to replace them with temporary foreign help, the Harperites scaled the program back.

Employers in the accommodat­ion, food-service and retail sectors were barred from using temporary foreign workers if the unemployme­nt rate in their region was greater than 6 per cent (an exemption was made for Yellowknif­e).

More important, the proportion of temporary foreign workers at any given workplace was to be capped at 10 per cent.

The Conservati­ves made the reasonable argument that if employers weren’t attracting enough Canadian workers they should offer higher wages.

But to help employers along and make sure these wages didn’t rise too much, the Conservati­ves also made it more difficult for the jobless to get employment insurance benefits.

On gaining power, the Trudeau Liberals turned the Conservati­ve plan on its head.

First, they announced plans to undo Harper’s employment insurance cutbacks.

That made it easier for jobless workers to turn down low-wage jobs.

Second, they dropped the radical suggestion that employers unable to find suitable Canadian workers should offer higher wages.

Instead, the Liberals threw in their lot with those who have built their businesses around low-wage labour. It is a potent lobby. In the Atlantic provinces, for instance, not only are the seafood processing plants in favour of cheap foreign labour but so are the fishermen who sell their catch to these plants.

Theoretica­lly, there is another way for low-wage operations to stay alive.

If they were unable to rely on cheap foreign labour, they might invest more in automation and become more productive. They might become part of what Finance Minister Bill Morneau calls his “innovation agenda.”

But as long as the federal government lets them bring in low-wage workers from abroad, most won’t go that route. Why should they? This is cheaper. Thomas Walkom’s column appears Wednesday, Thursday and Sunday.

 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada