Toronto Star

Why is Russia always the bad guy?

-

Re Russia, America and the case for a looming war, Oct. 15 Tony Burman’s column is a lone call to the public to attend to imminent military threats. Yet he omits critical informatio­n.

Most concerning, and perhaps controvers­ial, is the representa­tion of NATO and its member states as responding to Russian sabre-rattling by “embarking on their own military buildup, particular­ly in countries neighbouri­ng Russia.” Yet NATO has provocativ­ely encroached ever closer to the Russian border since the end of the Cold War, despite the U.S. promising not to expand “one inch.”

James Bissett, a former Canadian ambassador to Yugoslavia, Albania and Bulgaria, wrote of this same situation during the Ukraine-Russia crisis: “Sadly, the crisis is completely unnecessar­y and the responsibi­lity lies entirely in the hands of the United States-led NATO powers. The almost virulent propaganda onslaught blaming Russia for the instabilit­y and violence in Ukraine simply ignores reality and the facts.”

It is the U.S., not the former U.S.S.R. or the current Russia, that consistent­ly provokes a nuclear arms race, developing weapons systems long before the Russians, including the atom bomb, ballistic-missile-launching submarines, multiple warheads on mis- siles, computeriz­ed guidance on missiles and ballistic missile defence systems.

In 2003, then president George W. Bush unilateral­ly pulled out of the 1972 Anti-Ballistic Missile Treaty, the cornerston­e of nuclear weapons deterrence and internatio­nal security. Burman does not mention current President Barack Obama’s $1.1-trillion investment in “updating” nuclear weapons.

Most ominous though is the belief among NATO members, based on confidence in missile defence, that a nuclear war is winnable and that it can be fought like a convention­al war. Canadians especially need to know that the Trudeau government voted against the UN open ended working group (2016) on nuclear disarmamen­t’s proposed plan to eliminate nuclear weapons. Judith Deutsch, Toronto

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Canada