My husband fell out of love. What should I do?

Q: My husband of 15 years recently said that he’s no longer in love with me and needed time to figure things out.

He’s staying with his brother. Our two sons and I are in the family home, which is now for sale.

He rarely visits and only talks about the kids or the house. Now, he’s more convinced that it’s over for good. He said that it’s because I keep bringing it up and never gave him space. He’s detached and wants to move on.

Is there any chance for us to work it out if I stop talking about us and give it time? He doesn’t want a divorce, just to separate legally, presumably because it’s cheaper. How should I proceed? I love him and don’t want to lose our family. Devastated

A: Red flags — he’s calling all the shots: to separate instead of divorce, and to not allow you to even talk about your relationship.

I can’t help but think he may have already “moved on” and there’s another future partner waiting in the wings.

Even if not, you must talk to a lawyer and learn your rights and what suits your needs.

It’s shocking that the house where his and your children live is already for sale. Get your own legal advice about that immediately to review if that’s the right thing for you and the kids. See your bank manager and an accountant or financial adviser (not one working with him) and ask about your joint bank accounts and any assets/ investments.

By him not allowing discussion, the absence of marital counselling and you focusing only on wanting him back, you’ve so far ignored all the practical considerations that’ll affect your future and that of your children.

Don’t be afraid to confront him with strength of purpose and informed knowledge about what’s involved.

Even if you still love him, he needs to know that he’s dealing with an equal whose future is also at stake, not just his.

Q: I’ve been dating a woman for three years, both in our 50s. We met when she was going through a divorce (still processing).

Our relationship was initially beautiful, then she experienced crashes of intense depression, which I faced with great patience (sometimes wondering if the numerous medications were really helping). Last summer, I had to work elsewhere for a month and she wouldn’t keep contact. When I returned, I was restricted to seeing her only on specific days. She wants “no commitment” with me waiting until she’s ready to be my girlfriend. What should I do? Going Through Hell

A: Like a mirror opposite to the above question, this time it’s the woman being the controller and you’re kept hoping.

While children and property aren’t involved here, the effect is the same. You’re left in the dark about what’s really going on:

Has she met another man? Have any of the people treating her depression (doctor? therapist?) said she’s not capable now of making a long-term connection?

Whatever the answer, she should be sharing it with you. Instead, she’s issuing orders, putting up roadblocks.

I’m inclined to say walk away. But if you still love her, and have compassion for her depression, tell her so.

Then set a timeline for the break, one that feels reasonable for you.

You have a life to settle, too. Read Ellie Monday to Saturday. Email ellie@thestar.ca or visit her website, ellieadvice.com. Follow @ellieadvice.