Study reveals which communities are most at risk across Canada,
Suburban families, young urban renters vulnerable to economic downturn
New data from Environics Analytics highlights communities made vulnerable by coronavirus lockdowns across the country and profiles people at risk — such as young suburban families — that might get overlooked.
The data suggests where governments, businesses and social agencies need to focus supports and services as the economy takes baby steps toward reopening, Environics says.
“Governments are going to have to get more focused and pinpoint who they need to help and how,” said Rupen Seoni, senior vice-president at Environics Analytics. “We have to get the right help to the right people.”
The data, which Environics Analytics made available to the Star, scores Canada’s more than 850,000 postal code communities on how likely they are to be vulnerable financially, socially, and by how old and frail their residents might be. The data company also developed profiles of people most at risk in those categories.
The company used thousands of data points from a long list of sources, including its own demographic research, Statistics Canada, the Bank of Canada, Canada Post, aggregated credit scores, Canada Mortgage and Housing Corp., the census and surveys.
Environics found that the most financially vulnerable census metropolitan area in the country is Cold Lake, Alta., largely because of its reliance on the oilsands industry, which has seen the price of its product plummet during the pandemic’s economic fallout.
The least financially vulnerable is Canmore, also in Alberta, and the Greater Toronto Area fares only slightly worse. But the affluence indicated at Toronto’s metropolitan census level masks dense vulnerable pockets of people at the neighbourhood level, Environics notes.
Environics defines financially vulnerable people as those who will struggle to meet financial obligations like mortgages or utility bills if coronavirus lockdowns caused a sudden drop their income. It’s sadly no surprise that Indigenous people, after generations of colonialism trauma, appear in this cate gory as highly vulnerable.
More surprising, perhaps, is the high financial vulnerability of young suburban families.
According to Environics, the 700,000 households in this group are affluent when all is well. But they have relatively low savings — $57,000 on average — and a total debt that is double their household income of $105,000.
“They don’t have the liquid assets in savings to fall back on,” Seoni said. “They may be running into trouble in terms of having a sudden loss of income, based on their lifestyles.” Much depends on whether they’re able to continue working at home or in essential services during the lockdown.
Also highly vulnerable financially are “young urban renters,” Environics found.
“The younger renters in cities are not that highly indebted, they just don’t have that much income in the first place,” Seoni said. “When they lose their jobs, there’s just nothing left.”
Young single people in urban areas also face high levels of soac
restrictions on movement.
Environics Analytics defines social vulnerability as people likely to experience isolation and mental health troubles, while having limited social networks and supports. It's a challenge more prevalent in urban areas rather than rural ones.
Environics found that 36 per cent of young singles surveyed in cities reported feeling a weak sense of community belonging.
“Often, they are transplants into the big city, so their social networks tend to be weaker,” Seoni said. “A good number of them would be students … They’re alone in the city, almost.”
Newcomers to Canada also face high levels of social vulnerability, Environics found.
“What’s really driving it for these newcomers is a lack of social networks,” Seoni said. Something as simple as finding a trusted person to rely on for groceries, for example, can be a challenge, Seoni added.
Older people, particularly those on low incomes, and people with poor health, make up a group that, according to Environics, is vulnerable due to a high level of “frailty.”
The coronavirus has made only too clear the vulnerability of people in nursing homes. But the people Environics highlights are those not living in nursing homes, but whose frailty makes daily activities difficult.
The District of Guysborough, anchored by a port town in Nova Scotia has the highest frailty level of vulnerability in Canada, Environics found. Peel Region, west of Toronto, has one of the lowest, but Seoni again warns about the regionwide picture masking vulnerable pockets.
“In the big picture, you don’t have many frail citizens,” he said. “But they’re there and they need help.”