Reporter used deceit to connect with Diana
Probe finds ‘serious breach’ of guidelines in 1995 BBC interview
BBC journalist used “deceitful behaviour” to secure an explosive interview with Diana, Princess of Wales in 1995, in a “serious breach” of the broadcaster’s guidelines, according to investigation findings published Thursday.
The BBC appointed a retired senior judge in November to lead the investigation after Diana’s brother, Charles Spencer, made renewed complaints that journalist Martin Bashir used false documents and other dishonest tactics to persuade Diana to agree to the interview.
Spencer alleged Bashir showed him forged bank documents relating to his sister’s former private secretary and another former royal household member that falsely suggested the individuals were being paid for keeping the princess under surveillance.
He accused Bashir of using the documents to gain his trust so he would introduce Diana to the journalist. He also alleged that Bashir made up stories about the Royal Family to strengthen Diana’s belief there was a conspiracy against her.
The investigation criticized the BBC for falling short during its own probe into the matter two decades ago of the “high standards of integrity and transparency which are its hallmark.”
The BBC’s chair, Richard Sharp, said the corporation accepts the investigation’s findings, adding “there were unacceptable failures.”
Bashir, who was the BBC News religion editor, left the corporation last week on health grounds. He has been seriously unwell with COVID-19-related complications. In a statement, he said he deeply regretted faking the bank statements, calling it “a stupid thing to do.” But he added that he felt it had “no bearing whatsoever on the personal choice by Princess Diana to take part in the interview.”
Diana famously said in the interview that “there were three of us in this marriage” — referring to Prince Charles’ relationship with Camilla ParkerBowles. Her candid account of her failing marriage with Charles was watched by millions of people and sent shock waves through the monarchy.
John Birt, director general of the BBC at the time of the interview, which was aired on the “Panorama” news program, apologized to Charles Spencer in a statement.
“We now know that the BBC harboured a rogue reporter on ‘Panorama’ who fabricated an elaborate, detailed but wholly false account of his dealings with Earl Spencer and Princess Diana,” he said. “This is a shocking blot on the BBC’s enduring commitment to honest journalism; and it is a matter of the greatest regret that it has taken 25 years for the full truth to emerge.”
Diana divorced from Charles in 1996 and died in a Paris car crash in 1997 as she was pursued by paparazzi. Charles, the heir to the throne, married Camilla, now the Duchess of Cornwall, in 2005.
“In most organizations, the police would have been called to see if Martin Bashir should have been prosecuted for forgery, and he would have been instantly dismissed for deceit,” media lawyer Mark Stephens of law firm Howard Kennedy, who is not involved in the case, said. “Instead, the BBC made him their religious correspondent.”
The report released Thursday means the BBC will be subjected to more public scrutiny, he added.