In China, pollution is not up for debate
Government orders embassies to stop issuing readings to the ‘ outside world’
BEIJING — A senior Chinese official demanded on Tuesday that foreign embassies stop issuing air pollution readings, saying it was against the law and diplomatic conventions, in pointed criticism of a closely watched U. S. embassy index.
The level of air pollution in China’s heaving capital varies, depending on the wind, but a cocktail of smokestack emissions, vehicle exhaust, dust and aerosols often blankets the city in a pungent, beige shroud for days on end.
Many residents dismiss the common official readings of “slight” pollution in Beijing as grossly understated.
The U. S. embassy has a monitoring point on its roof that releases hourly air- quality data via a widely followed Twitter feed. The U. S. consulates in Shanghai and the southern city of Guangzhou provide a similar service.
While China improved air pollution monitoring standards in January, the official reading and the U. S. embassy reading can often be far apart. Chinese experts have criticized the single U. S. embassy monitoring point as “unscientific.”
Deputy Environment Minister Wu Xiaoqing went a step further, saying such readings were illegal and should stop, though he did not directly name the United States.
“According to the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations ... foreign diplomats are required to respect and follow local laws and cannot interfere in internal affairs,” Wu told a news conference.
“China’s air quality monitoring and information release involve the public interest and are up to the government. Foreign consulates in China taking it on themselves to monitor air quality and release the information online not only goes against the spirit of the Vienna Convention ... it also contravenes relevant environmental protection rules.”
Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Liu Weimin called on foreign diplomatic missions to respect China’s laws and regulations and to stop issuing the readings, “especially over the Internet.”
“If the foreign embassies want to collect this kind of information for their own staff and diplomats, I think it’s up to them,” Liu told reporters. “They can’t release this information to the outside world.”
In Washington, the State Department said it did not believe the pollution monitoring reports violated either Chinese laws or the Vienna Convention and that the embassy would continue to release them.
“This is a service that we provide to Americans both who work in the embassy community as well as Americans who live in China,” State Department spokesman Mark Toner said.
“Air pollution quite frankly is a problem in many cities and regions in China,” Toner said. “This is just information that we provide to the American community so they can make decisions based on the safety of outdoor activities.”
The U. S. embassy acknowledges on its website (http://beijing.usembassy- china.org.cn) that its equipment cannot be relied upon for general monitoring, saying “citywide analysis cannot be done ... on data from a lone machine.”
Despite his criticism, Wu acknowledged that China’s air quality and overall environmental situation remained precarious, with more than onetenth of monitored rivers rated severely polluted, for example.
“What needs saving is the country’s air quality, not the government’s face,” Zhou Rong, an energy campaigner for Greenpeace, said in emailed comments. “The environmental authorities must stop fingerpointing and start taking actions that really address the issue.”