Value stocks shield investors from worst of storm thrashing markets
Value stocks are providing investors some shelter from the storm sweeping markets, as portfolio managers seek out bargains and dump high-flying companies that have been in vogue since the wake of the financial crisis.
The MSCI World value index has fallen around seven per cent in 2022 on a total return basis, far better than the 25-per-cent tumble for the index provider's growth index.
The strong relative returns have meant that an investment strategy in which traders purchase shares in global companies that are cheap compared with metrics such as book value and profits, and bet against groups that are expensive, has generated returns of almost 30 per cent so far this year, according to Bloomberg data.
The renaissance started more than a year ago, but the so-called value factor's powerful rise in 2022 has reinforced belief that this is now a durable shift in market conditions.
“There is a regime shift underway,” said Yoram Lustig, head of multi-asset solutions for Europe and Latin America at asset manager T. Rowe Price Group Inc.
Growth investing has dominated as central banks unleashed successive rounds of stimulus to shore up the world economy against the financial crisis in 2008 and the coronavirus crisis in 2020. The measures, including setting interest rates at historically low levels, helped inflate the prices of companies not expected to reach peak profits for years to come.
Value investors, in contrast, have struggled over the time period as their performance lagged behind.
“We survived the worst decade for value in history and now we're enjoying the fruits of the rebound,” Rob Arnott, founder and chairman of Research Affiliates, a consultancy, said.
Nick Kirrage, co-head of the global value team at London-based asset manager Schroders PLC, said the valuations of growth stocks had become so overstretched that an eventual reversal was inevitable.
“Valuation is a bit like a big elastic band,” he said. “You can stretch it so far and then it comes back. Valuations can't expand forever; they tend to come back to a median over time.”
Analysis by quantitative investment firm AQR Capital Management shows that the value spread — which is the dispersion between the valuation of growth and value stocks — is still nearly as stretched compared with historic norms as it was during the peak of the dot-com bubble in 2000.
“This is a giant mispricing,” AQR founder Cliff Asness said. “I believe that the ridiculous spreads that we're seeing mean that value is going to make a lot of money in the next three-plus years.”
Asness said AQR has cautioned clients, nevertheless, that there are still likely to be resurgences in growth stocks along the way. “Sticking with (the value bet) when it's incredibly painful is the source of outperformance. But we don't think it will get back to full crazy.”
Vanguard Group Inc. expects American value stocks to deliver annualized returns of 4.1 per cent over the next 10 years compared with just 0.1 per cent for growth stocks.
And a shift in sentiment is starting to be borne out in exchange-traded fund flows among American investors. Growth-focused ETFs listed in the United States have registered net outflows of US$2 billion in the first four months of 2022, partially reversing the positive inflows of US$38.2 billion over the whole of last year, according to data from State Street Corp.
Meanwhile U.S.-listed value ETFs have gathered net inflows of US$37.6 billion in the first four months of the year, following US$60.3 billion net inflows during 2021, State Street said.
Despite this rotation, the vast majority of investors — many of whom have become conditioned to “buy the dip” in recent years — are still contemplating whether to increase their exposure to value stocks, said Richard Halle, portfolio manager at M&G Investments.