Guarded response to less lethal strains as daily cases hit record 40,052
The latest Covid-19 waves on the mainland have revealed more transmissible but less lethal strains of the coronavirus, but it is too early to be optimistic, public health experts have warned.
Just days after Beijing relaxed some zero-Covid measures, infection numbers in the current outbreak hit a new high of 40,052 yesterday, with 36,304 yet to show symptoms.
As of yesterday, 104 cases were identified as “severe”, with seven deaths recorded so far. All patients who died were aged above 80 and had comorbidities.
The waves risk burdening the health system and if the mainland were to change its response, it should put fewer resources into mass testing and more into vaccination and public education, according to an epidemiologist.
Covid-19 infections have been on the rise across the mainland since last month, believed to be driven by new subvariants of the highly infectious but less deadly Omicron strain.
The number of severe cases, however, has been comparatively low.
Professor Benjamin Cowling, head of epidemiology and biostatistics at the University of Hong Kong, said this needed to be interpreted with caution as there was usually a two-week lag between infection and more severe clinical outcomes.
“We need to be careful in interpreting the current mortality rates because it can take two to three weeks from infection to death, and we are still in the middle of the current outbreaks. There is likely to be more deaths in the coming weeks,” Cowling said.
The mainland’s total infections have surpassed the peak of the massive spring outbreak in Shanghai, driven by the Omicron variant and prompting months of lockdown.
About 600 people died of the disease out of 650,0000 infected in the wave that lasted from March to May, according to a paper published in the online journal China CDC Weekly in September.
Another study, led by infectious diseases expert Zhang Wenhong and released in June, found less than 0.7 per cent of the 33,816 Omicron patients surveyed in Shanghai had developed severe or critical infections.
Allocating more resources for serious cases instead of mild ones should be the way forward, the researchers said.
China’s healthcare system might not be able to handle Omicron waves in case of a winter surge, Cowling warned, saying authorities might need to reconsider their containment strategy to mitigate the impact.
Authorities have held fast to a dynamic zero-Covid policy, which relies on cutting transmission chains as soon as possible with mass testing and snap lockdowns.
They said the mainland’s healthcare system could not afford to “live with the virus” and unchecked spread amid the vast population would mean an explosion of severe cases and death.
Last year, the ratio of intensive care beds on the mainland – the world’s
No 2 economy – stood at 4.53 per 100,000 people, with the numbers varying greatly across provinces.
By comparison, the ratio is 33.9 per 100,000 in Germany, 28.9 in Australia and 25.8 in the United States. Meanwhile, specialist intensive care doctors only account for 0.8 per cent of the total practising doctors.
“I think China’s healthcare system will struggle to cope with a large surge in infections this winter,” Cowling said.
“Omicron is so contagious and case numbers could rise so quickly that even though most infections are mild there will still be a peak with probably too many severe cases for the healthcare system to manage at the same time.”
And when zero-Covid became too difficult to maintain because it would require more stringent measures, longer lockdowns and more mass testing – on top of growing fatigue with the measures and their social and economic impact – China would have few options but to move away from the policy, Cowling said. “If stringent measures are not sustainable, the case numbers will increase. If it becomes impossible to reduce case numbers back down to zero nationwide, even with prolonged lockdowns and repeated mass testing, there may be no alternative but to transition away from those stringent measures,” he said.
Some preparations need to be made to cope with a change in response, if that indeed happens, according to him.
Mass polymerase chain reaction tests should be scrapped and the resources transferred elsewhere, Cowling suggested.
“Mass testing will not help much in mitigation,” he said.
“This is more of a containment measure, and rapid tests may be a more efficient way to allow diagnosis of mild infections.”
The government should also come up with policies for home quarantine of mild cases and close contacts, give up the health tracking app and relax travel restrictions, he said, as “they are not necessary once transitioning away from a zero-Covid strategy”.
Experts have long pushed for boosting vaccination rates, especially for the elderly, as a significant and urgent measure to protect the most vulnerable groups and prevent the mainland’s healthcare system from collapsing once curbs are eased.
Only 5 per cent of the fatal cases in Shanghai earlier this year were vaccinated, the China CDC Weekly paper in September noted. “The last 10 per cent in any vaccination campaign is the most difficult to reach,” it said.
By November 11, about 86 per cent of people over 60 years of age had been fully vaccinated on the mainland, with 68 per cent boosted. For those over 80, however, the figures were 66 per cent and 40 per cent, respectively, according to the national health office.
Professor David Hui Shu-cheong from the Chinese University of Hong Kong, who advises the city government on its pandemic response, also pushed for higher vaccination rates on the mainland.
“They need to boost the population, especially high-risk groups, with vaccines of other technology platforms, such as protein subunit vaccines, adenovirus vaccines or mRNA vaccines, to enhance the antibody response,” Hui said.
Beijing’s mass vaccination campaign has relied mostly on locally developed inactivated shots, which use dead material from the Covid-19 virus to trigger an immune response.
“Containment policy is not a long-term solution for managing the Covid-19 pandemic,” Hui said.
“[The mainland] should adopt a heterologous vaccination approach [that is, mix and match] and not just rely on inactivated whole virus vaccines alone.” High-risk patients should be treated early with oral antiviral agents as well, he said.