Under-threat primary school’s private class bid rejected

Education chiefs have ruled out private classes as an alternative survival plan for a primary school which had its request for a review of its operations rejected.

The Education Bureau’s reply on Monday night came hours after the school’s alumni association vowed to raise HK$3 million to run private Primary One classes to save it from the axe.

The Po Yan Oblate Primary School is among five campuses that will not get government grants to operate Primary One classes from the next academic year after they enrolled only 15 children for the entry-level class, one short of the minimum.

The school may face complete closure in September 2026.

Pang Siu-fong, chairwoman of the Wong Tai Sin school’s alumni association, said her organisation wanted to raise the cash to pay for private classes, but the school had not made a final decision.

Pang said it was unfair that another school located near the border, Sha Tau Kok Central Primary School, had retained its government support despite a failure to enrol sufficient pupils.

“It is a kind of injustice … our school serves students with special education needs [SEN] wholeheartedly,” she said.

The campus was the only one among the five threatened schools that applied for a review by Education Bureau officials. To pass muster, it would have needed to have scored a “good” rating in all performance indicators.

But sources said the request was turned down because the school failed to secure the “good” or above rating in its self-evaluation exercise, a requirement for an external review.

The bureau said it had met school representatives and people from its sponsoring body last Monday to explain why they were rejected for a review.

It added that the school could submit a response to the bureau’s decision within a specified time.

“The bureau also made it clear in the meeting that because the school had opted to apply for a special review and it was rejected, it cannot choose another option,” it said. “That is, it will not be able to participate in the Primary One admission system again, nor can they apply to operate Primary One classes privately in the 2023-24 school year.”

Declining to comment on the bureau’s remarks, Pang yesterday said her association had not started any fundraising activities and had no such plans for the time being.

Some parents and pupils on Saturday petitioned Secretary for Education Christine Choi Yuk-lin to talk to them after she attended an event at an institution in Lok Fu in the morning. But the meeting did not take place after the bureau rejected the group’s request to allow the media to attend.

The bureau later said it was also “not ideal for schoolchildren to be exposed to hot weather for an extended period of time”.

A parent, who identified herself as Mrs Chu, whose child is in Primary One and has special needs, told a radio programme on Monday that she at first expected Choi would come out to reassure them and suggest meeting at another time.

“[Choi] did not even pretend she cared … she should have come and received our letter and arranged a time slot to meet us, but she chose to leave,” she said.

Chu added that the group wanted the media present to make sure the discussions were transparent.

The parent said her child enjoyed learning at Po Yan Oblate as its teachers were experienced in special education needs tuition.

“When choosing schools for my kids to be promoted to Primary One, I called around a dozen schools,” Chu said.

“Only this one could give me an impression of how they could integrate students with SEN into the whole school and let them lead a normal campus life and not segregate them.

“If such a good school needs to be axed, it will be a loss to students, not just students with SEN, but also those whose academic performance is not so good.”

A spokeswoman for the bureau said earlier considerations for the operation of Primary One classes included whether the school was in a remote location and whether there were other institutions nearby.

The school declined to comment on the former pupils’ proposal.

Another four schools facing the axe have managed to survive.