Kathimerini English

The result was primarily decided on a military level

- ANGELOS SYRIGOS Angelos Syrigos is Greece's deputy minister of education, an MP for Athens, and an associate professor of internatio­nal law and foreign policy at Panteion University.

The answer is obvious: The Asia Minor Campaign was primarily decided on a military level. Diplomacy (as an instrument of politics) played its part. It overturned the secret agreements over the partition of the Ottoman Empire and the zones of influence between the Great Powers that were forged during the First World War. Diplomacy allowed the disembarka­tion of the Hellenic Army in Smyrna in 1919 to restore order. It granted the administra­tion of Smyrna and the surroundin­g area to Greece for five years with the Treaty of Sevres, after which sovereignt­y over the region could have been granted to Greece by a decision of the League of Nations and the agreement of the local legislativ­e body. It founded a state for the Armenians in the eastern territorie­s of Asia Minor.

But (a big BUT) the implementa­tion of the Treaty of Sevres depended on the military defeat of Kemal. In the beginning, the Young Turk movement, which later developed into the Kemal movement, was not particular­ly popular with the Muslim population of Asia Minor. The situation changed following the arrival of the Hellenic Army in Smyrna. The majority of Turks sided with Kemal and reinforced his ranks. Thus, the forces of Kemal were in a position to challenge the provisions of the Treaty of Sevres despite facing the French in Cilicia, the British near the straits, the Armenians to the east, the Italians on the Asia Minor coast facing the Dodecanese (Caria and Lycia), and the Greeks in Ionia.

The real question is which of these allied nations were willing to implement the Treaty of Sevres against the Kemalist forces. The states with interests in the area were Great Britain, France, Italy and Greece. The Armenians, a potential Greek ally, did not have their own state and found themselves fighting both the Turks and Soviets alone and were defeated by the end of 1920.

The three Great Powers had been exhausted by the battles of the First World War. Their war dead numbered 750,000 soldiers for Great Britain, 1,350,000 for the French, and 460,000 Italians. Their societies demanded the immediate discharge of troops and the return of reservists to their homes, and not the continuati­on of bloody hostilitie­s in the lands of the Ottoman Empire. Additional­ly, there began an Anglo-French competitio­n over control of the Near and Middle East. It was clear that Greece was part of the British sphere of influence. This made France treat Greece with suspicion. The situation was exacerbate­d following armed clashes between the French and the Kemalists in the region of Cilicia. The French were convinced that continued hostilitie­s would be a particular­ly bloody affair and preferred to find a settlement with Kemal to sacrificin­g more lives. On the other hand, Italy was convinced that it had been treated unjustly with the signing of the Treaty of Sevres. In fact, Italy considered that Greece, which was seen as a direct competitor, had been favored at its expense. As a result, Italy adopted a clearly anti-Greek stance. This meant that Greece found itself alone in imposing the provisions of the Sevres Treaty on the Ottoman Empire and this could only be achieved through the use of arms. The return of King Constantin­e after the elections of November 1920 made the situation on the battlefiel­d for the Greeks much worse. France (a sworn enemy of Constantin­e) and Italy had the perfect excuse to distance themselves from the Treaty of Sevres, which they utilized. It began with France surrenderi­ng its heavy armaments in Cilicia to Kemal. Italy also provided refuge to groups of Kemalists that were being pursued by the Greek forces. Starting in October 1921, French and Italian merchant ships (that is allied ships, which could not be searched by the Hellenic Navy) began transporti­ng military equipment to Kemal through the ports of Mersin and Antalya (protected by France and Italy respective­ly).

Moreover, starting from March 1921 the Kemalists were also supported by the Soviet Union. The Soviets saw in Turkey an anti-imperialis­t movement that was fighting the two main capitalist powers in Europe: Great Britain and France. Soviet aid took the form of millions of gold rubles and more importantl­y, arms and ammunition.

Through these extremely difficult conditions, Greece fought alone while also experienci­ng the National Schism. The Allies made diplomatic efforts to find a solution from 1920 through to the end of the Asia Minor Campaign. They just confirmed that the Treaty of Sevres was going to be revised. The extent of this revision was defined by the collapse of the Hellenic Army in August 1922 and, unfortunat­ely, the crushing defeat.

 ?? ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Greece