‘Costly’ power pacts saddle UP discoms

Losses of electricity distribution companies (discoms) in Uttar Pradesh — already among the highest loss-making utilities in the country — are mounting owing to the unusually high cost of power procurement. While the average power price (including short-term market) has gone below ~3 per unit, UP continues to source it at higher rates. The last state government signed long-term power purchase agreements for 5,056 megawatt at ~3.2-5 per unit in 2015.

Losses of electricity distribution companies (discoms) in Uttar Pradesh — already among the highest loss-making utilities in the country — are mounting, owing to an unusually high cost of power procurement.

While the average power price in India (including shortterm market) has gone below ~3 per unit, UP continues to source it at higher rates, thanks to the long-term power purchase agreements (PPAs) signed for 5,056 Mw at ~3.2-5 per unit in 2015.

Major power plants from which the state sources electricity are Harduaganj (~5.1/unit), Bajaj Hindustan (4.71/unit), Hindustan Power (~4.7/unit) and Rosa (Reliance Power) (4.33/unit). The state sourced around 4,000 million units (MUs) last year at ~4.2-4.9 per unit from these plants.

The high cost of power procurement could be a major problem for debt-ridden discoms, particularly at a time when the new state government has promised 24 hours of power supply.

“When compared to the prices at the short-term or spot power market, UP could have saved ~1.5-2 per unit. The savings roughly translate into ~500 crore, as against the cost of long-term power,” said a sector executive. The total variable cost paid by UP during April December 2016 was close to ~1,690 crore to procure 3,962 MUs at an average cost of ~4.5 per unit from various power plants. Such costs are passed on to the consumers.

Of its total power drawl of 9,281 megawatts (Mw), UP sources 4,225 Mw from interstate generating stations, 228 Mw through long-term agreements, 364 Mw medium-term agreements, 150 Mw bilateral trade, 26 Mw through shared agreements. The state currently procures no amount of power from power exchanges.

UP had a peak energy demand of 8,000 MUs in March this year. This could climb up to 10,000 MUs during peak summer months.

Experts pointed out that such long-term PPAs would have made sense four years back when the prices were less, but now a 25-year agreement at over ~4 per unit was not prudent. “The power prices due to several variables such as coal prices, increased congestion in network have led to power producers increasing the variable tariff. Spot prices, however, are coming down,” he said.

UP currently procures nothing from spot power market despite 13,500 Mw available at around ~2.5 per unit.

The BJP in its poll manifesto promised 24-hour power supply to all by 2019. The five discoms of UP, ailing with a debt totalling ~54,000 crore, are under financial restructuring under the UDAY scheme. While the debt has been serviced through bonds, any future funding would depend on the operational efficiency of the discoms.