Learning from troubled past, Germany moves to tame FB
Security is tight at this brick building on the western edge of Berlin. Inside, a sign warns: "Everybody without a badge is a potential spy!"
Spread over five floors, hundreds of men and women sit in rows of six scanning their computer screens. All have signed nondisclosure agreements. Four trauma specialists are at their disposal seven days a week.
They are the agents of Facebook. And they have the power to decide what is free speech and what is hate speech. This is a deletion centre, one of Facebook's largest, with more than 1,200 content moderators. They are cleaning up content — from terrorist propaganda to
Nazi symbols to child abuse — that violates the law or the company's community standards.
Germany, home to a tough new online hate speech law, has become a laboratory for one of the most pressing issues for governments today: How and whether to regulate the world's biggest social network.
Around the world, Facebook and other social networking platforms are facing a backlash over their failures to safeguard privacy, disinformation campaigns and the digital reach of hate groups.
In India, seven people were beaten to death after a false viral message on the Facebook subsidiary WhatsApp. In Myanmar, violence against the Rohingya minority was fueled, in part, by misinformation spread on Facebook. In the United States, Congress called Mark Zuckerberg, Facebook's chief executive, to testify about the company's inability to protect its users' privacy.
As the world confronts these rising forces, Europe, and Germany in particular, have emerged as the de facto regulators of the industry, exerting influence beyond their own borders. Berlin's digital crackdown on hate speech, which took effect on January 1, is being closely watched by other countries. And German officials are playing a major role behind one of Europe's most aggressive moves to rein in technology companies, strict data privacy rules that take effect across the European Union on May 25 and are prompting global changes.
"For them, data is the raw material that makes them money," said Gerd Billen, secretary of state in Germany's Ministry of Justice and Consumer Protection. "For us, data protection is a fundamental right that underpins our democratic institutions."
Germany's troubled history has placed it on the front line of a modern tug-of-war between democracies and digital platforms.
In the country of the Holocaust, the commitment against hate speech is as fierce as the commitment to free speech. Hitler's "Mein Kampf" is only available in an annotated version. Swastikas are illegal. Inciting hatred is punishable by up to five years in jail.
But banned posts, pictures and videos have routinely lingered on Facebook and other social media platforms. Now companies that systematically fail to remove "obviously illegal" content within 24 hours face fines of up to ^50 million.
Now companies that systematically fail to remove "obviously illegal" content within 24 hours face fine of up to ^50 million