Down to Earth

COVID-19/GLOBAL

- MUTUAL AID

the usefulness of the work. Supermarke­t workers, delivery drivers, warehouse stackers, nurses, teachers, and doctors are the new CEOs.

It’s possible that state socialism emerges as a consequenc­e of attempts at state capitalism and the effects of a prolonged pandemic. If deep recessions happen and there is disruption in supply chains such that demand cannot be rescued by the kind of standard Keynesian policies we are seeing now (printing money, making loans easier to get and so on), the state may take over production.

There are risks to this approach—we must be careful to avoid authoritar­ianism. But done well, this may be our best hope against an extreme COVID-19 outbreak. A strong state able to marshal the resources to protect the core functions of economy and society.

HOPE IS FOR A STRONG, DEMOCRATIC STATE THAT MOBILISES RESOURCES TO BUILD A STRONGER HEALTH SYSTEM, PRIORITISE­S PROTECTING THE VULNERABLE FROM THE WHIMS OF THE MARKET

Mutual aid is the second future in which we adopt the protection of life as the guiding principle of our economy. But, in this scenario, the state does not take a defining role. Rather, individual­s and small groups begin to organise support and care within their communitie­s.

The risks with this future is that small groups are unable to rapidly mobilise the kind of resources needed to effectivel­y increase healthcare capacity, for instance. But mutual aid could enable more effective transmissi­on prevention, by building community support networks that protect the vulnerable and police isolation rules. The most ambitious form of this future sees new democratic structures arise. Groupings of communitie­s that are able to mobilise substantia­l resources with relative speed. People coming together to plan regional responses to stop disease spread and (if they have the skills) to treat patients.

This kind of scenario could emerge from any of the others. It is a possible way out of barbarism, or state capitalism, and could support state socialism. We know

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from India