A sports boycott doesn’t help

To counter Pakistan, diplomatic and military options are better

After the terrorist attack in Pulwama, different methods of punishing Pakistan are being discussed. Among them is a cricket boycott of the country. The Indian team is scheduled to play a match against Pakistan in the ICC Cricket World Cup in June in England. The suggestions range from boycotting that match to using India’s heft in the International

Cricket Council (ICC) to throw Pakistan out of the quadrennial event. Vinod Rai, the man at the helm of Indian cricket, has argued that Pakistan should be boycotted from sporting events in the manner that apartheid-era South Africa once was.

The sports boycott against South Africa’s white ruling regime was indeed effective. South Africa was expelled from the Olympics in 1964. By 1970, more than 20 governing bodies of different sports had boycotted the country. But this is the only example of a successful sports boycott. The US boycott of Moscow Olympics in 1980 failed to generate any sort of impact against the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan — the event which triggered the boycott. The Soviet Union and its allies retaliated by boycotting the 1984 Los Angeles Olympics. A number of Arab countries regularly boycott Israeli athletes but have failed to develop a global movement against Israeli “occupation” of Palestinian territory.

The sports boycott against South Africa worked because it achieved a global consensus. It is difficult to sustain a boycott on grounds of terrorism as opposed to racism. Terrorism has been used by almost every major power to achieve its political objectives. As a result, terrorism is unfortunately still not seen as an unalloyed evil like racism is. In such circumstances, it will be difficult to generate a consensus in the ICC as well as the International Olympic Committee (IOC) against Pakistan. Brinkmanship on India’s part may even lead to embarrassment. The nonissuance of visas to Pakistani shooters for the World Cup in Delhi has already led to India’s censure by the IOC. If India wants to punish Pakistan, it should look at the options on the military, diplomatic and economic side of the ledger, and leave sports and arts alone.