Small group of home buyers can’t seek bankruptcy proceedings against a defaulting realty company
To avoid misuse of the insolvency proceedings by some home buyers who are seeking action against well-run real estate companies, government may bring in minimum threshold of home buyers which will be required to start such bankruptcy proceedings.
“A lot of representations have come that a single home buyer who could be a speculative home buyer also is trying to dislocate an otherwise well-operating real estate company. In Mumbai, a lot of such cases have been admitted and half the cause list comprises of real estate companies. These have to be looked at in a very innovative manner. We may have to look at some threshold such as 5% which is there for class action or a threshold of one fifth of home buyers which have for mismanagement in operation. We may have to find some measures to check abuse,” corporate affairs secretary Injeti Srinivas said on Tuesday at the third annual day function of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India.
Earlier this year, the Supreme Court (SC) ruled that the home buyers’ rights will remain at par with the lenders making them financial creditors. The apex court has upheld the ability of home buyers to take real estate developers into bankruptcy proceedings.
A three judge bench headed by Justice Rohinton F Nariman said that once a home buyer establishes default before a bankruptcy court, the onus is on the builders to prove that the consumer does not wish to take possession of their house to avoid proceedings.
Srinivas said the government is in the process of operationalising personal insolvency in phases which may take a year to become fully functional. “The Bankruptcy Process for personal guarantor to corporate debtor is almost finalized. The next is “fresh start” process through which relief will be given to very small borrowers who are not in a position to repay the debt. This will be rolled out in next four to six months time. Then insolvency process for proprietorship, partnership and other matters will be taken up subsequently,” he added.
The bankruptcy process for very small defaulters will be a non-adjudicating process, Srinivas said. “It will be a total online system to prove veracity of the application and assets of the person among other things,’ he added.
Srinivas said the framework for cross border insolvency based on UNCITRAL Model Law is ready and will be taken up by the Parliament during the upcoming winter session. Crossborder insolvency is one where the defaulting company has assets in more than one country or where some of the creditors of the company are not from the country where the insolvency proceeding is taking place. Government is also readying a framework for group insolvency, Srinivas said.
The corporate affairs secretary said the government is very keen to develop a marketplace for stressed assets so that maximum competition and participation of the foreign investors also possible. This will lead to realization of maximum value for assets and we may get the best people to run these companies,” he added.
How has the ongoing NBFC liquidity crisis impacted real estate firms?
Pirojsha Godrej: The impact has clearly been quite bad. Not that the situation was good before this, but this crisis has worsened the liquidity environment for the real estate sector. In yet another
Five years into the real estate slowdown, how has the consolidation story played out in the residential sector?
In terms of strong balance sheets and sales numbers, there are top 5-10 developers who have significantly grown in the last five years, and it is a good opportunity to gain market share compared to
GPL has considerably expanded its portfolio as distress deepened during these slowdown years. What kind of opportunities do you see now?
Despite the pessimism, as we add new projects and enter new micro-markets in large cities and deepen our presence, our market share will rise in the short term. With the sector undergoing challenging times, we saw huge opportunities and needed to be well-capitalised. The equity raise
Given that the residential sector is still under stress, what kind of homes are selling today?
It’s evident that smaller units and more affordable projects have sold better than luxury homes. But sales are also dependent on the right product for a certain micro-market. If customers today perceive any risk associated with the developers or in under-construction projects, they will stay away. Developers who have a good track record and better credibility are better positioned in the current market. For instance, our premium project launches have also done well.
What’s GPL’S take on affordable housing?
By the government’s definition of affordable homes, priced at ₹45 lakh and below, we already have a fair amount of projects in that category. But we don’t need a separate vertical for affordable projects
GPL bought RK Studios in Mumbai earlier this year. What’s the current status?
We are working on the design right now. It’s going to be largely a high-end residential development with some retail. We plan to launch the project by the end of this financial year.
What is the road ahead like for the sector? Do you expect a recovery anytime soon?
To estimate the time that the sector would take to recover is tough. It could take six months or a year.
But inventory levels are reducing and project launches are happening, so the turnaround is expected to happen soon. I believe the foundation and the conditions of the next turnaround are being laid now. There are only a few developers today who are planning expansion, new projects.