Hindustan Times ST (Mumbai) - Live
What India can learn from British politics
In the end it was a coronation. That it happened on Diwali would have mattered personally to the 42-year-old devout Hindu. However, I want to make a different point. Rishi Sunak’s uncontested election as the leader of Britain’s Conservative Party and, therefore, the country’s new prime minister (PM), the youngest in over 200 years, makes me very proud of my second favourite country. It also raises a poignant question about our own. Will India learn the obvious lesson from Britain?
Consider for a moment what the United Kingdom (UK) has done: 6.8% of its population is of various Asian origins. 2.3% of the country is of Indian parentage. This is a minuscule minority. Yet, the Conservatives have made the son of first generation immigrants of Indian origin, who only came to the country in the 1960s, the country’s 57th PM. The reaction in our own country is proof of both our disbelief this could happen and our delight it has.
Although Sunak’s elevation may be the most striking development, it’s by no means the full story. 20% of Boris Johnson’s first cabinet was of Black or Asian origin. The previous four chancellors, the last two home secretaries and the most recent foreign secretary came from immigrant families. These are considered great offices of State. Perhaps most tellingly of all, by some counts, over 200 of the Conservative Party’s 357 MPs supported Sunak. None of the white contenders could even make it to the starting point.
Now, let’s turn to India. Muslims are 14.3% of our population. So, in proportionate terms, they should have 78 seats in the Lok Sabha. They have only 27. India does not have a sitting Muslim chief minister in any of its 28 states, in 15 there’s no Muslim minister, and in 10 there’s just one, usually in-charge of minority affairs. Today, the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) doesn’t have a single Muslim MP in either House of Parliament. In Uttar Pra
IN INDIA, WE HAVE PERHAPS 200 MILLION MUSLIMS BUT THEY HAVE BEEN INVISIBILISED.
SO, TODAY, WHEN WE TAKE PRIDE IN SUNAK’S METEORIC RISE, WHY DON’T WE ALSO LOOK AT OURSELVES AND ASK: COULD A MUSLIM PM BE POSSIBLE IN INDIA?
desh, with nearly 20% Muslim population, the party doesn’t have a single Muslim member of the legislative assembly (MLA). That was also true in 2017. In Gujarat, it hasn’t fielded a Muslim candidate in any Lok Sabha or Vidhan Sabha election since 1998. That’s 24 years of deliberate distancing although 9% of the population is of the Islamic faith.
The facts I’m quoting are from Aakar Patel’s book Our Hindu Rashtra. It reveals even more disturbing details. The book says Muslims are only 4.9% of state and central government employees, 4.6% of the paramilitary services, 3.2% of Indian Administrative Service, Indian Foreign Service and Indian Police Service officers, and perhaps as low as 1% of the Army. This should embarrass us.
Let me cite the media in Britain to illustrate the contrast. Look at the BBC and you’ll be stunned by the profusion of Asian origin faces. Here are some you are bound to have seen: Matthew Amroliwala, Geeta Gurumurthy, James Coomaraswamy, George Alagiah, Nomia Iqbal, Sameera Hussain, Amol Rajan, Rajini Vaidyanathan, Yogita Limaye, Secunder Kermani, Kamal Ahmed, Faisal Islam, Dharshini David.
So, now, can you see why I hope India will learn the obvious lesson from Britain? We have perhaps 200 million Muslims but they have been effectively invisibilised. We call them termites and Babar ki aulad, taunt them with references to abba jaan, reduce them to comparisons between shamshan ghat and kabristan and repeatedly tell them to go to Pakistan. So, today, when we take pride in Sunak’s meteoric rise, why don’t we also look at ourselves and ask: Could a Muslim PM be possible in India?
There’s an even stranger paradox that most people fail to notice. Those of us who least understand Britain are often the first to claim the British are racist. Long before Sunak’s ascension, they were terribly wrong. But they’re also usually the last to criticise, or, indeed, even acknowledge, the treatment of Muslims at home. Instead, they prefer to talk of appeasement.
I pray the Sunak story might be an inspiration for us. I fear I will be proven wrong.