Questions over EVMs; EC swears by machines

In the midst of the elections, questions are being raised by many opposition parties over the Electronic Voting Machines (EVMs) after about 10,000 of these machines malfunctioned at different places during the first three phases of the polls. The Election Commission (EC) has deployed a total of 2.34 million EVMs for balloting at over a million polling stations across the country.

Of these, the actual deployment of EVMs is just over 2 million with the poll panel having kept 250,000 units as buffer for replacements. Further, the EC strong rooms have 83,000units which are “locked” with previous election petitions, said sources.

EC sources said they have noticed three types of malfunctioning in the EVMs -- the paper rolls in the VVPATs getting stuck, keys getting jammed and EVMs and VVPATs (paper trail) suffering lack of synchronisation just as a computer needs to be connected to the printer.

They said two types of machines, M2 and M3, are being used in the Lok Sabha polls. Out of the total 2.34 million units, 550,000 are M2 type and 1.79 million M3 type. The M3 is an improved version of M2 and is better designed to handle any attempt to tamper with the EVM. Insisting that the EVMs are tamper proof, the EC sources said the machines have gone through rigorous checks and the representatives of various political parties are involved at all the stages when the machines are used.

“The EC is conducting the national polls with the help of around 10 lakh (one million) government staff. Lack of training

or mishandling of the machine by some persons could be the reason behind these complaints,” the sources said.

EC sources said a technical review committee is looking into these issues and has suggested some changes in the specifications of paper rolls which are of certain thickness and have been designed to carry the imprint for five years, but sometimes face problems in humid conditions.

The Congress, Nationalist Congress Party (NCP), Telugu Desam Party (TDP), Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) and Samajwadi Party (SP) have all questioned the credibility of the EVMs.

The charge by various opposition parties is based on two points - that the ruling BJP allegedly tampers with the machines to get votes and that the malpractice goes against the basic tenet of democracy and fails to provide a level playing field to all the contestants. The opposition parties have urged the EC to go back to the old paper ballot system while claiming that the EVMs have been rejected by many developed countries.

“It is the responsibility of the poll panel to clear the doubts in the minds of the voters over the credibility of EVMs. Therefore, we had asked for 50 per cent VVPATs to be matched with the votes polled,” Congress spokesperson Abhishek Manu Singhvi said. Congress MPS from Thiruvananthapuram Shashi Tharoor charged that votes polled for other parties were all going to the BJP by default.

EC sources said the machines were replaced after the fault was detected.

Former EC official S.K. Mehndiratta, who was involved in the introduction of EVMs, backed the machines, saying the opposition’s charges were not based on evidence.