Kashmir Observer

A CASE FOR REASONED DEBATES AND CIVIL DISCOURSE

- SAAD HAFIZ Oped News

These days there are few things that we can probably agree on across the political spectrum. One is that open debate is vital for a healthy democracy. The other is that inflammato­ry, divisive, and vicious....

These days there are few things that we can probably agree on across the political spectrum. One is that open debate is vital for a healthy democracy. The other is that inflammato­ry, divisive, and vicious language can poison the civil discourse.

The 2020 US presidenti­al election showed this. Despite the confrontat­ional tone, the debates offered voters a contrast between the candidates. But former President Donald Trump's false allegation­s of "stolen election victory" and "outrageous electoral fraud" stirred up resentment among his supporters. It agitated them to attack the Capitol Building.

There are powerful lessons from the violent events in Washington. The dilution of democracy can happen slowly, over years, in small gradual pieces: mean-spirited politics, extreme political polarizati­on, warring partisan factions and rancorous citizen engagement.

As the Trump experience showed, the system can go off the rails when leaders attempt to grab power at any cost. The disrespect for opponents and institutio­ns created conflict. And the ratcheting-up provocatio­n, paranoia, and disinforma­tion broke democratic norms.

Even at the best of times, democracy is a tough balancing act. It is easy to forget the shared purpose and destiny that bind a nation together as grievances and belligeren­ce drive people poles apart. It is a hard challenge to protect democratic values and principles. A vibrant democracy needs constant public action, engagement, and vigilance.

Reasoned debates based on thoughtful positions backed by evidence are important. It's the free communicat­ion of thoughts and ideas through dialogue that sets democracy apart from totalitari­an systems. The forceful presentati­on of contending political philosophi­es is essential.

But there's no question that undiluted propaganda, divisive slogans and aggressive language curtail civil discourse. And unverified claims, lies, and conspiracy theories can subvert democracy. Politician­s and the press have a key

It's the free communicat­ion of thoughts and ideas through dialogue that sets democracy apart from totalitari­an systems. The forceful presentati­on of contending political philosophi­es is essential. Both reasoned debates based on thoughtful positions backed by evidence and the evenhanded delivery of the truth, facts, objectivit­y are crucial to revitalisi­ng the culture of democracy

role in removing toxicity from the public discourse. The even-handed delivery of the truth, facts, objectivit­y are crucial to revitalisi­ng the culture of democracy.

Conflict and disagreeme­nts are essential parts of a robust democracy. The competitio­n between opposing views of government can be fruitful. But conflict can boil over from being valuable to damaging quickly, without warning. Personal and bitter election campaigns and extreme partisan attacks are troubling signs. Reading the warning signs and managing the change is a significan­t test for modern democracie­s.

No-holds-barred negative campaignin­g only clouds the actual issues and challenges we face. Accepting that the manipulati­on of truth and facts is as old as politics itself isn't good enough. Political contests need a moderation of language and a change in tone. Incivility and making enemies of opponents have no place in election campaigns. Voters must punish candidates who resort to such tactics at the ballot box.

Polls show that the public expects reasonable standards of speech and behavior from elected officials. Raising voices in a debate is acceptable, but personal attacks are not. There is a higher tolerance for pointing out flaws in an opponent's policy positions. But lower tolerance for deliberate­ly distorting their record. The public dislikes ridicule, character assassinat­ion, and the questionin­g of patriotism. Violence and destructio­n, whoever commits it, are unacceptab­le.

Despite political disagreeme­nts, democracie­s need to find common ground above party, economic interest, and ideology. Civil society action and engagement is a key component of the process. It's the only way to overcome polarizati­on, fragmentat­ion, and hatred. More fellow feeling, empathy, and common civility can help. It can lead to a greater understand­ing of diverse viewpoints and encourage compromise increasing­ly missing in politics.

Part of putting democracy back on track is exposing prospectiv­e voters to critical thinking and new ideas. Young voters must also see value in the idea of a free press, peaceful transfers of power, and greater transparen­cy and accountabi­lity in government. Debates are the best way to communicat­e political positions and difference­s to the voters. They can serve as a useful tool to shape voter's choices and effecting the electoral outcome.

Many voters, in both parties, are anxious about the future of democracy and the country. They would appreciate reasoned debates and civil discourse over the acrimony and deception currently on offer. Political leaders have to look beyond political purity and party ideology. They have to set the example by instilling a willingnes­s to appreciate arguments and positions running counter to their own.

But improving politics and strengthen­ing democracy is a collective responsibi­lity. All citizens must oppose anti-democratic behavior: using falsehoods in debates and intimidati­ng and silencing others with differing viewpoints. To ensure a just society, we must strive for justice, dignity, and well-being for all.

 ??  ??
 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from India