#Caught on camera
right!
When in May, blogger Amelia Liana uploaded a stunning photograph of herself at the top of the Rockefeller Center, gazing out at a view of the New York City skyline, a few eagle-eyed followers quickly noticed that something was up. One of the commenters pointed out that One World Trade Centre (formerly called Freedom Tower) — which was completed in 2013 — was notably missing from the city’s skyline. According to Mail Online, one person wrote, “Cute! That’s pre-World Trade Centre (the new one) though…the skyline is very, very different now.” The image has since been removed from Liana’s feed.
With more than 461k followers, Liana’s recent ‘fake’ acts/posts include a photo where she poses outside the Taj Mahal sans the massive crowds of tourists normally seen outside the famous landmark, and her messed up reflection that ended at the edges of the pool while the Taj Mahal’s reflection got compressed to fit in it. The result — unstoppable trolls.
Bloggers say that editing is considered acceptable but one shouldn’t go too far. You can use several techniques to enhance, sharpen or smarten images, but not up to a maddening extent.
Travel blogger Kanika Sood points out, “As a travel blogger the first thing to keep in mind is the authenticity of your content. Secondly, always use your own image, no matter what. You simply can’t pick up a stock image from someone or somewhere and edit your own self inside that picture. That’s ethically wrong.”
Prachi Garg and Himadri Ga rgofGhoo mop hiro sisters, who started travel blogging when there were only a few travel bloggers, say, “Though everyone wants to portray their journeys in the best way possible in this content-driven digital world, you will find the depth and experience missing in some travel bloggers. We still follow the veterans, as they are digital nomads in the true sense. We normally do not edit our pictures apart from adding our watermark and cleaning them a bit. The prime reason behind this is to maintain the originality of the place. We understand that many people follow us for our musings and get eager to see the places through our experiences. Giving them a fake picture via too much picture editing is an injustice.”
However, in an era where everyone out there uses Instagram filters to enhance photographs, it’s not fair to point out anyone in particular, opines Purushu Arie, a fashion blogger. He says, “Every blogger uses Photoshop. The precedent was set long ago and bloggers are just mirroring an already existing custom (which they didn’t even create.) Photoshop is a wonderful tool to enhance lighting, textures and other aspects that make a wonderful photograph. But I think the use of Photoshop shouldn’t be projected as the main problem here. The main problem occurs when you’re not honest with your audience. Photoshop, like everything else in the world, can be put to both good and bad use.” Kanika agrees, “As a travel blogger, you are talking or communicating with your public or your followers through your visual content, so they can’t be ugly or average. They have to be pretty and inspiring. Here, Photoshop enters your workshop if you like using it. As a photographer, you have a subject which you want to highlight. So for example, if you have Taj Mahal as your subject, you can probably use tools to clean up your image so that the subject gets adequate highlighting. But whatever it may be, you have to be a pro. Audiences can’t be fooled so easily.” Lastly, she adds, “However, as a travel blogger, you have access to a grey area. For instance, you are travelling to a said destination where you may have clicked a lot of pictures but due to some reasons, you were not able to post them on your social media account while you were on the go. So, when you come back home, you go ahead and post them, but without the pretence of being in that same destination while posting. You can probably mention them in the form of hashtags like #latergram #throwback, etc. so that you don’t mislead your followers.”
As blogger Amelia Liana gets called out for Photoshopping Instagram images of herself at stunning locations around the world, we speak to travel bloggers on the ethics of editing, and the price of faking it I think the use of Photoshop shouldn’t be projected as the main problem here. The main problem is when you’re not honest with your audience — As a travel blogger the first thing to keep in mind is the authenticity of your content — KANIKA SOOD, travel blogger PURUSHU ARIE,