CAG report useless, doubt timing: PC

It was deliberately presented on budget session’s last day

Dismissing the CAG report on the Rafale jet deal as worthless, senior Congress leader P Chidambaram said in New Delhi on Thursday it was presented deliberately on the last day of the budget session of Parliament to escape the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) scrutiny.

“The Comptroller and Auditor General (CAG) has meekly submitted to the unprecedented demand of the government and presented a report that contains no useful information, analysis or conclusions,” Chidambaram said a day after the report was tabled in Rajya Sabha.

While the Modi government and the BJP have hailed it, Chidambaram called the report useless and reiterated Congress’s demand for a Joint Parliamentary Committee (JPC) probe. “The report, besides being silent on crucial issues, is yet to be examined by the PAC.”

The CAG report is significant not for what it has said, but for what it has not. Criticising it for not divulging the pricing details, Chidambaram said it neither threw light on the justification to reduce the number of aircraft from 126 to 36 nor to the monetary gain to Dassault due to amortisation of the India-specific enhancement costs. “What is the monetary gain to Dassault and the monetary risk to India because of the waiver of the sovereign guarantee, the bank guarantee and the escrow account? What is the hidden purpose of waiving the mandatory anti-corruption clauses: no undue influence, no agency, access to books of account and integrity pact,” the ex-Union FM asked.

About Dassault’s backlog of over 80 aircraft, he said the report is silent on the delivery date of the first and the last of the 36 aircraft. “The CAG is not god and its report not final. Parliament is supreme. That’s why want a JPC, which can call for and examine all the documents related to the deal. The CAG has allowed his office to become a joke, but an honourable govt, that is to come, will restore its prestige and honour,” he said.

That is why it was submitted on the last day of the budget session. The Lok Sabha has been adjourned sine die and the report will not be examined by the PAC before the Lok Sabha polls. The entire exercise was aimed at hiding things. The report is not even worth the paper it is printed on.

— P CHIDAMBARAM, CONG