Chalisa was a Rana ruse to seek MVA ouster: Cops

The Mumbai police have opposed the bail pleas of member of Parliament Navneet Rana and member of the legislative assembly Ravi Rana, saying that the couple had orchestrated the Hanuman Chalisa row, to use it as a ploy to plead the collapse of law and order in Maharashtra. This, in turn, was to become a ruse for seeking the dissolution of the Maha Vikas Aghadi government.

The police filed an 18-page affidavit in reply on Friday, opposing their bail pleas and further alleged that the issue was raked up to create an impression in the minds of the general public that the state government, of which the Shiv Sena is a part, is hostile towards Hindus and it is difficult for Hindus to practise their religion freely.

The Ranas have been charged under section 124A of the Indian Penal Code for sedition after they declared that they would recite the Hanuman Chalisa outside Matoshree, the residence of Chief Minister Uddhav Thackeray.

The affidavit read: “The plan to read the ‘Hanuman Chalisa’ at the private residence of the Chief Minister at Matoshree is a big plot to create a challenge to the law and order situation and to the maintenance of law and order by the Government established by the rule of law, to such an extent that the collapse of law and order can be pleaded and the recommendation can be made for dissolution of the present government by the Governor of Maharashtra.”

It further added that the reading of a religious text like the Hanuman Chalisa at a private residence without prior permission of the owner would amount to “trespass”.

It further states that one cannot threaten or challenge the government that s/he will act against the procedure established by law; instigate and incite other persons and at the same time dare the government to stop such an act, even “when the same is under the guise or veil of a chanting of religious book”. Also, the reply stated that the words spoken by Ranas “were not within the reasonable limits of the