The Hindu (Thiruvananthapuram)
Mohiniyattam exponent’s remarks trigger controversy
A controversy over whether casteism corrodes the world of classical arts in Kerala erupted on Thursday with Mohiniyattam artiste R.L.V. Ramakrishnan claiming that he was the latest victim of allegedly institutionalised upperclass privilege in the haloed halls of traditional dance.
Mr. Ramakrishnan said Mohiniyattam exponent Kalamandalam Sathyabhama’s attempt to set “fair complexion and agreeable looks” as prerequisites for performing arts was “brazenly racist and insulting” to artistes from marginalised and poor sections of society. Without naming any artiste in particular,
Ms. Sathyabhama recently told a social media channel that Mohiniyattam was traditionally best performed by artistes with “fanciable looks and pale skin tones.”
She also purportedly opined that persons who “resemble crows and are resented by their mothers for their looks” had no place in the classical dance and were, at best, alsorans.
Stance defended
Ms. Sathyabhama defended her stance somewhat combatively when television reporters confronted her at her residence in Thiruvananthapuram. The artiste said she had quoted the principles of Natyashastra, an ancient Indian text on performance arts, and did not mean to insult any person, caste, or colour. She feared no prosecution for speaking out the truth.
The Purogamana Kala Sahitya Sangham, an organisation of progressive writers, artists, and literature enthusiasts, condemned Ms. Sathyabhama’s statement and demanded that the police investigate her for disparaging artistes from Dalit communities.
The controversy also highlighted the difficulties artistes from marginalised sections of society faced in negotiating the allegedly stratified world of classical arts.
Heated public debate
It also prompted a heated public debate on whether such intrinsic prejudices pervaded the world of fine arts in progressive Kerala.
The ruling Left Democratic Front (LDF) government, the Congressled United Democratic Front (UDF) Opposition and the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) supported Mr. Ramakrishnan and condemned the allegedly casteist remarks.
Higher Education Minister R. Bindu said in a social media post that some individuals still harboured “a decayed feudal mindset.” Society would reject their casteist and colour prejudice with the derision such revanchist attitudes deserved, she said.
Dr. Bindu said artistes like Mr. Ramakrishnan, through their nuanced and interpretative performances, had “liberated Mohinyattam from the ignominy of being an art form that objectified the feminine form for the amusement of erstwhile feudal lords.” Mr. Ramakrishnan had unshackled Mohiniyattam from the “chains of licentious mudras and elevated it into a more sublime classical art form.” Minister for Welfare of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes K. Radhakrishnan said the police would initiate a case if Mr. Ramakrishnan preferred a complaint. Minister for Culture Saji Cherian has demanded that Ms. Sathyabhama apologise for the remarks.
Kerala Kalamandalam Deemed University ViceChancellor B. Ananthakrishnan said it is a black mark for the institution to add its name with the people who make such demeaning remarks which do not suit a civilised society. Other than being an old student of Kalamandalam, she does not have any links with the institution now, he said.