The Sunday Guardian

PM MODI SCRIPTED INDIA’S VICTORY OVER UK IN UN

President Donald Trump was decisive in changing US position on India.

- MADHAV NALAPAT NEW DELHI

Those involved with the successful campaign to ensure victory for India’s Dalveer Bhandari in the elections to the Internatio­nal Court of Justice (ICJ), say that more than the UK, which has no seat on the Internatio­nal Criminal Court at Geneva for the first time in the history of that institutio­n, it is Pakistan that has been devastated by India’s candidate prevailing over the UK’s Christophe­r Green- wood, who like Bhandari has already served a nine-year term on the court. Since June this year, when Prime Minister Narendra Modi finally intervened to make his team swing into action to secure a second term for the courtly judge, Rawalpindi GHQ concurrent­ly made the Government of Pakistan go into diplomatic overdrive to ensure that Bhandari lost. Islamabad’s hopes were raised after the candidate from Lebanon overtook the Indian candidate in the race for the lone “Asia” seat, thereby forcing a contest against the UK, a permanent member of the UN Security Council instead. Given that none of the “Permanent 5” (US, China, Russia, France and the UK) had ever lost an election to another country before, it was conveyed by diplomats to Prime Minister Narendra Modi that the chances for a Bhandari victory were “not substantia­l”. Modi, however, decided to go ahead with the contest, despite the risk of losing, arguing that it was important that India oppose the tradition of a privi- leged P-5 member always prevailing over an ordinary member of the UN, such as India. Reform of the archaic UN system has been made a foreign policy priority of the PM, and part of the proposed alternativ­e construct (to the 1944 Bretton Woods architectu­re that has been left unchanged since then) is to ensure adequate weightage to the General Assembly, rather than have this huge body constantly defer to the Security Council (specifical­ly the P-5) in matters coming up for decision within the UN system. Hence, rather than waste much effort on the Security Council (which could be expected to follow the tradition of supporting one of their own against other countries), India’s UN envoy, Syed Akbaruddin was told to concentrat­e his efforts within the General Assembly, which he began doing from 20 June onwards, once briefed on the importance that Modi was placing on this election.

Those spoken to say that the matter involving Kulbhushan Jadhav’s capture

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from India