The worst informers for Britain in Irish history Francis Magan - Betrayed 1798 leader Lord Edward FitzGerald

Given the long history of British occupa‐ tion of Ireland, it is hardly surprising that informers flourished.

There are few words that the Irish de‐ test more than “informer”. Remember Victor McLaglen as Gyppo Nolan in the Oscar-winning 1935 movie "The In‐ former"? It portrayed the dreadful end for an Irish informer.

Yet, in real life, it happened. Here are the worst of the breed:

“Stakeknife” Freddie Scappaticci - IRA informer

The grandson of Italian immigrants to Northern Ireland, Scappaticci was named as “Stakeknife” the key informer within the IRA in 2003. “Stakeknife” is believed to have been the most high-ranking British agent within the Provisional IRA. He is said to have been the head of the IRA’s internal secu‐ rity unit known as the “nutting squad,” responsible for the brutal interrogation and murder of as many as 30 people be‐ lieved to be IRA informers.

While working as the IRA's chief spy catcher, “Stakeknife” was, in fact, feed‐ ing information to the British Army, overseeing the murder of informants within the Republican movement while also working with British security forces.

Stakeknife worked for the top-secret Force Research Unit (FRU) of the British Army.

He had his own handlers and agents, and he was important enough that MI5 set up an office dedicated solely to him. He got paid £80,000 sterling ($100,000 ) a year.

He disappeared soon after being named. It is believed that he has returned to Northern Ireland just once for his fa‐ ther’s funeral in 2017.

In 2018, Scappaticci, living at a secret English address, was found guilty of possessing scores of violent pornography images and got a threemonth suspended jail sentence

Denis Donaldson - IRA Informer

On December 16, 2005, Sinn Féin pres‐ ident Gerry Adams announced at a press conference in Dublin that Denis Donald‐ son, a top Sinn Féin official, had been an agent for British intelligence. This was confirmed by Donaldson in a statement which he read out on RTÉ, the Irish state broadcaster, shortly afterward.

Donaldson had been influential in the Sinn Féin American outreach strategy and was well known in Irish American circles where he was a frequent visitor. In his statement, Donaldson stated that he was recruited after compromising himself during a vulnerable time in his life but did not specify why he was v ex‐ posed. Donaldson disappeared after ad‐ mitting his role as an informer.

On March 19, 2006, a journalist found him at a cottage near Glenties, County Donegal. Shortly after, on April 4, 2006, Donaldson was found shot dead inside the cottage. A dissident IRA group claimed responsibility.

James McPartland - Informed on The Molly Maguires

Between 1877 and 1879, 20 Irishmen known as the Molly Maguires, Irish emi‐ grants fighting for better conditions in the Pennsylvania coal mines, were exe‐ cuted. They were fighting horrific condi‐ tions in the mines and vicious owners intent on keeping unions out of their lu‐ crative business.

They were convicted b the informer tes‐ timony of a fellow Irishman, James Mc‐ Parland, an Armagh native who was sent in by the Pinkerton Agency to infiltrate the Molly Maguires. Previously McPar‐ land had worked as a laborer, policeman, and liquor dealer before going broke and becoming an informer on his own. Within a short time McParland, using the name James McKenna, had success‐ fully infiltrated the Mollies and even be‐ came secretary of the local AOH lodge. Some of his reports back to the agency ended up in the hands of local vigilantes who murdered several Irish miners and the wife of one Irish union militant. De‐ spite this McParland continued to in‐ form on his fellow Irishmen.

What took place because of him ac‐ cording to historian Harold Aurand, was "one of the most astounding surrenders of sovereignty in American history. A private corporation initiated the investi‐ gation through a private detective agency; a private police force arrested the alleged offenders; the coal company attorneys prosecuted them. The state only provided the courtroom and hang‐ man

The trials of the Molly Maguires began in 1876 with the star witness for the prosecution being McPartland. He showed no nervousness or fear sending his fellow Irishmen to the gallows. He subsequently had a long career with the Pinkertons

Francis Magan was one of Dublin’s lead‐ ing barristers and passed himself off as a true Irish nationalist. In reality, he was an informer for the crown, responsible for the capture and death of Lord Ed‐ ward FitzGerald the charismatic leader of the United Irishmen in Dublin who was to lead the United men in taking over Dublin military installations in 1798 Rising.

Magan professed to be a United Irish‐ man and turned informer after he de‐ manded £1000 from the British for in‐ formation leading to the arrest of Fitzgerald. With the money secured, Ma‐ gan went to work.

To trap FitzGerald, Magan organized a meeting of the Dublin United Irishmen in his own house, on the night of 17 May 1798. Lord Edward got away on that oc‐ casion but two nights later just a day before the Dublin insurrection was plan‐ ned Magan led authorities to FitzGerald's secret hiding place. FitzGerald was shot in his bed and died two days later.

It was almost a century later when Mag‐ an’s treachery was revealed when his‐ torical records of the time were opened up.

McNally was perhaps the most treach‐ erous spy in Irish history, A Dublin bar‐ rister, he joined the United Irishmen revolutionary group led by Theobald Wolfe Tone and Lord Edward FitzGerald. The group influenced heavily by the French and American revolutions sought to bring Irish “Catholics, Protestants and Dissenters” together.

After plans to seek aid from France for the United Irishmen were uncovered, McNally was implicated and turned in‐ former to free himself.

After his death in 1820, it was revealed he was making $400 a year from the British as an informer McNally was paid an annual pension in respect of his work as an informer of £300 a year, from 1794 until his death in 1820.

The United Irishmen met frequently at McNally’s home and he informed on every activity they planned and who the plotters were.

To add insult to injury, McNally as a trusted Irish barrister represented the revolutionaries at their trials. He kept the Crown prosecution aware of every defense maneuver and likely witnesses Incredibly still an informer, he was Robert Emmett’s lawyer after his illfated 1803 revolution. Again he kept the Crown informed of Emmett’s every move and legal strategy. Robert Emmett never had a chance.

In 1997, the Sinn Féin newspaper An Phoblacht described him as "undoubt‐ edly one of the most treacherous in‐ formers of Irish history" in an article about McNally.

Richard Newell - 1798 informer

Richard Newell was a United Irishman who was also an informer based in Belfast and spying on United Irishmen in the 1790s.

His younger brother, Robert described Newell as being "in the practice of going through the town of Belfast disguised in the dress of a light horseman, with his face blackened and accompanied by a guard of soldiers, pointing out certain individuals who have in consequence been immediately apprehended and put in prison".

Newell later repented and wrote a book revealing all. Newell claimed that £2,000 was given to him as a reward for causing 227 innocent men to be jailed.

James Carey - Fenian informer

Carey was part of the Irish Invincibles, an off-shoot of the Fenian movement who killed two senior British officials af‐ ter attacking them in Phoenix Park Dublin in 1883.

Carey was caught and turned informer leading to five co-conspirators being hanged.

Carey was now a known informer and fled Ireland on a boat to South Africa under the name of Power. Unluckily for him on board was Fenian Patrick O'Don‐ nell, who found out who “Power” was and shot Carey dead as they reached land.

The informer’s death was greeted with parades and joyous scenes in Ireland.

The two unknown 1916 Informers

Two informers known only as code names Granite and Chalk were sending intelligence about the 1916 Rising plan to Dublin Castle, files from the period revealed.

Granite and Chalk revealed arms dumps and reported the movements of leaders of the upcoming Rising. But Granite and Chalk did not stop the Rising.

To this day their real names cannot be identified.

IrishCentral History

Love Irish history? Share your favorite stories with other history buffs in the IrishCentral History Facebook group. * Originally published in September 2022. Updated in March 2024.

IrishCentral Staff