Jury clears fisherman of Irish dad’s murder after he ‘fell on to screwdriver’
A FISHERMAN has been found not guilty of murdering an Irish father of two in Australia.
Andrew Doan (35) was accused of fatally stabbing Charles John McCarthy (32) in the head with a screwdriver during a fight next to Perth’s Swan River in 2017.
After brief deliberation, jurors found Mr Doan not guilty of both murder and an alternative charge of manslaughter following a trial in the Supreme Court of Western Australia.
The court heard how Mr Doan had been fishing with his friend Tien Vu Huynh in East Fremantle in the early hours of December 23, 2017, when Mr McCarthy, his wife Nicole, and friend Jason Mikel Curran walked by.
Mr Doan said that when the men saw him and Mr Huynh emerging from the water, they asked: “Have you caught much?”
He mumbled “Not much” in reply and they shot back “Bit of s*** luck”, according to Doan.
Their next comment – along the lines of “Fisheries are going to come and get you” – upset him and Mr Huynh, who are both Asian and interpreted it as racist.
The trio walked off but Mr Doan pursued them and a verbal argument erupted.
Mr Doan said his anger soon gave way to feeling vulnerable and outnumbered when Mr McCarthy began “puffing up” and walked back towards him “really staunch” with his fists clenched. “It looked like he was coming into a demonic rage,” Mr Doan said.
He said he panicked, reached into his hoodie pocket, pulled out a screwdriver he had been carrying for crabbing and held it above his head, saying: “Get back or I’ll stab you.”
Mr Doan said that as he retreated to his car, he had a scuffle with Mr Curran and Mr McCarthy kicked a wheelie bin at him, which just missed.
He said Mr McCarthy then charged and moved to punch him.
The court was told that at this point Mr McCarthy’s wife was frantically pleading with him to stop, but he ignored these calls and impaled himself on the screwdriver, which Mr Doan was still holding.
Mr Doan insisted he had closed his eyes, thrown his arms up to protect his face and forgot the tool was in his hand.
When he opened his eyes, Mr McCarthy was on the ground, Mr Doan said.
He remained at the scene until emergency services arrived, telling police “it was me”, and claiming self-defence.
Mr McCarthy’s brother Dan and twin sisters Siobhán and Sinéad had travelled from their home in Cork to attend the trial.