The Irish Mail on Sunday

Can Kenny lift the curse of Shatter the undead?

- Sam sam.smyth@mailonsund­ay.ie Smyth

ALAN SHATTER is departed but remains politicall­y undead, a troubled and troubling presence lurking on the backbenche­s. And Enda Kenny needs to sharpen his wooden stakes to finally rid the coalition of his malign influence. The former minister was at the heart of the Ceann Comhairle’s near-death experience, averted at the eleventh hour last week.

Seán Barrett acceded to Shatter’s demand that the Dáil not debate an inquiry into the Guerin report, which precipitat­ed his resignatio­n.

But Enda Kenny let him (Shatter) know the inquiry’s terms of reference a month before anybody else; it looked like a favour for an old friend.

When he was in Cabinet, Shatter attacked Seán Guerin SC and the Garda whistleblo­wers under the cover of Dáil privilege.

After his resignatio­n, he demanded long and loud to be given an opportunit­y to clear his name.

HE continues to pursue his grievances about the Guerin Report and the findings of the Data Commission­er in the civil courts. Shatter tried (unsuccessf­ully) to have his name removed from the inquiry’s terms of reference but he did stop the Dáil discussing it.

To a layman, that smacks of having your legal cake and eating it too.

Perhaps Shatter’s efforts are all in the name of the administra­tion of justice but some believe that maybe they really are more about Alan.

The Ceann Comhairle debacle was just the latest in a long series of Shatter-inspired fiascos that tossed the Government from chaos to crisis.

But the Taoiseach and his Cabinet are still in awe of the former minister for justice’s apparently supernatur­al legal powers.

Some former colleagues seem fearful of him and a few may even wear a clove of garlic around their neck when he is around. How can the Oireachtas not debate an inquiry where Shatter will be a central figure?

The suspicion is that it was because of a letter his lawyer sent to keep him out of any parliament­ary discussion.

Q: Can one former minister’s clever legal manoeuvres dictate how our parliament does its business? A: On the Guerin report, yes. Mr Shatter is entitled to the same legal protection as any other citizen; but it is balanced against his duty as an influentia­l public representa­tive to encourage openness and transparen­cy.

Big Phil Hogan’s water charges debacle inflicted a grievous wound on the Coalition but Shatter’s suite of fiascos have come close to draining the life blood out of the Government.

If Big Phil Hogan was a lumbering Frankenste­in’s monster, Shatter is the sophistica­ted, aloof aristocrat flitting down from his dark castle to suck the credibilit­y from Fine Gael.

Judge Fennelly’s report into the resignatio­n of the Garda Commission­er may yet entwine the fates of Shatter and the Taoiseach in a fatal embrace.

Enda Kenny quotes mythical people from phantom interviews but he needs real firepower for a showdown with his politicall­y undead nemesis.

Where is the Taoiseach to find his Van Helsing?

Political Draculas are not a recent phenomenon: the late Conor Cruise O’Brien, the most articulate opponent of Charles Haughey, wrote: ‘If I saw him buried at midnight at a crossroads with a stake driven through his heart, politicall­y speaking, I should continue to wear a clove of garlic around my neck, just in case.’

Maybe Enda Kenny should take a leaf out of Cruise O’Brien’s book for a Bram Stoker-inspired epitaph on Shatter.

 ??  ??
 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Ireland