The Jerusalem Post

No comparison

-

Although Seth J. Frantzman, in “Europe exported ISIS jihadism as it once did Nazism” (Terra Incognita, October 10), does, quite correctly, paint a horrific picture of Islamic State crimes carried out by European collaborat­ors, I think it is a mistake to equate this with the events of the Holocaust.

As Prof. Yehuda Bauer of Yad Vashem has repeatedly pointed out, the Holocaust was a unique event in modern history marked by its own “unpreceden­tedness,” wherein 6 million Jews throughout Europe were systematic­ally hunted down, dehumanize­d and singled out for total annihilati­on using the latest technologi­cal methods – just because they were Jews.

The unpreceden­tedness of the Holocaust made it the yardstick against which other mass killings could be compared and measured, which is probably what Mr. Frantzman was trying to do. However, I believe that to equate other killings, no matter how egregious, with the unpreceden­ted events of the Holocaust is to diminish its uniqueness and the lessons to be learned. MARION REISS Beit Shemesh

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Israel