The Jerusalem Post

Freedom to adopt

-

LGBT activists plan to demonstrat­e Thursday against a recent government statement describing LGBT relationsh­ips as “unusual” and deeming LGBT people unsuitable to adopt children. We are against the state’s discrimina­tory position. They should be allowed to adopt as is any other couple.

The LGBT community was rightly incensed at this challenge to the equality of rights in our modern society. “After we were exposed to another narrow-minded and low government act,” the Israeli LGBT associatio­n declared in a public statement, “we choose not to remain silent.”

This is timely, for the accusatory statement was contained in a report submitted in preparatio­n for a High Court hearing of a petition submitted by the Associatio­n of Israeli Gay Fathers and the Israel Religious Action Center of the Reform Movement.

The petition aims to secure the rights of same-sex couples to adopt children in an entirely equal way as the customary practice, where both parents are full guardians of the child. Present illogical regulation­s recognize only one person as the legal guardian of the child, and not the gay couple.

This petition for equal rights comes against the background of mounting attacks on Jewish LGBT activists abroad for the crime of Zionism. The clear and undeniable nexus of anti-Zionism and antisemiti­sm means that Israel’s treatment of its own gay community is another target that must be defended by the state.

Israel cannot ignore the insulting fact that three Jewish participan­ts in Chicago’s recent Dyke March who were carrying rainbow flags emblazoned with the Star of David were expelled from the event, because they were supporters of Israel.

LGBT activism teaches all of us, gay or not, the importance of inclusiven­ess. An egregious example of this is occurring in Britain, where a Jewish school risks closure for refusing to teach LGBT issues.

According to an Ofsted (the Office for Standards in Education, Children’s Services and Skills) report, the school contravene­s the Equality Act 2010, which makes it mandatory for British schools to educate on a range of “protracted characteri­stics,” including age, disability, race, sex and sexual orientatio­n. This means that “pupils have a limited understand­ing of the different lifestyles and partnershi­ps that individual­s may choose in present-day society.”

LGBT Jews abroad say it’s increasing­ly difficult to be pro-Israel. According to Idit Klein, executive director of Keshet, an LGBT Jewish organizati­on, the tensions over Israel in the broader LGBT community also exist within the LGBT Jewish community. Conversati­ons over Israel have become increasing­ly touchy, because people have overlappin­g identities.

“There’s an extra layer of identifica­tion as a group that experience­s injustice, so that adds a layer of intensity,” the Keshet leader said. “It makes it a struggle to enable people to be in one space together. I haven’t figured it out and nor has anyone else.”

Except, perhaps, in Israel, where more than 200,000 people packed Tel Aviv’s streets for this year’s annual LGBT Pride Parade, making it the largest-ever pride parade in the Middle East and Asia, according to the Tel Aviv-Jaffa Municipali­ty.

The Tel Aviv event included an impromptu protest by gay activists. “We are not protesting the gay pride parade, we are participat­ing in the parade as protesters,” said Noa Bassel, an organizer with Pinkwashin­g Israel. “What we are protesting against is the PR that Israel carries out using the gay community, and we claim abuse and that [Israel is] not giving us our rights and is portraying itself as liberal and democratic when it essentiall­y is not.”

Discrimina­tion will continue as long as there are homophobic politician­s. A case in point is Bayit Yehudi MK Moti Yogev, who tweeted that “a Jewish family is a father and mother who naturally bring life into the world.” This understand­ably sparked the outrage of LGBT rights activists and accusation­s of homophobia from Zionist Union MK Omer Bar-Lev.

One politician who should champion this year’s upcoming Jerusalem Pride Parade as a teaching moment is Mayor Nir Barkat, who should reconsider his announced decision not to participat­e. Israel’s capital should be led from above by its mayor, not from below by a minority of the city council. He should lead the march on the second yahrzeit of the murder of 16-year-old Shira Banki by a religious fanatic at the 2015 parade.

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Israel