Gen Z’s pragmatism to end polarization
Gen Z voters have been credited with halting the predicted “red wave” in the 2022 midterm elections. These young voters turned out en masse for Democrats Nov. 8; CNN House exit polls show that 63 percent of Gen Zers voted for Democrats, which was a much higher percentage than for older generations. Just 43 percent of those over 65 voted for Democrats while 55 percent cast ballots for Republicans.
But this midterm outcome does not mean that voters in this new generation are dedicated Democrats. In fact, they would be better described as pragmatists and issue-oriented voters.
Gen Zers showed up at the polls in large numbers and voted in 2020 to push out Donald Trump. They engaged again this year because they wanted to take a stand against extreme positions promoted by many on the right. They turned to Democratic candidates who supported abortion rights and opposed the Trumpian movement to deny election results, and they rejected a host of extreme candidates in places like Arizona and Pennsylvania.
At the same time, this generation largely lacks strong party attachments if we look at their political and ideological attitudes. This is made quite clear by College Pulse’s Future of Politics survey, which queried 1,552 undergraduate students at 91 colleges and universities at the start of the school year.
When asked about how they see the major political parties, today’s college students are anything but enthusiastic. Less than a quarter of all students (21 percent) — Democrats and Republicans included — believe that the Democratic Party is acting in the best interests of democracy and just 25 percent feel the same way about the GOP.
And when asked whether the parties are moving in the right or wrong direction, just 18 percent of all college students think that the Democratic Party is moving in the right direction; the number is a bit higher for the Republican Party. Cynicism about the parties’ future is the norm, with roughly half of all students being pessimistic about both parties.
Interestingly, a poll released in late October by Harvard University’s Institute of Politics found that 57 percent of young voters ages 18-29 preferred Democratic control of Congress while 31 percent preferred GOP control; 12 percent were undecided. Yet only 32 percent of college-age voters identify as liberal, with another 19 percent claiming to be conservative. The plurality of students — 48 percent — call themselves moderates.
The Future of Politics survey uncovers a similar breakdown with young voter party affiliation — 31 percent report that they are Republican and another 33 percent Democrat. The remaining 37 percent are either unaffiliated or independent. Gen Z looks very different from those in the Silent Generation — President Joe Biden’s and Nancy Pelosi’s generation, which has seen a decline in independent voters and a rise in Republican identification in 2022.
Gallup corroborates these trends and found that younger generational groups are more likely than their older counterparts to be centrist and less partisan. Millennials appear to be fairly stable centrists, unlike earlier generations, which have become more partisan over time.
Gen Z’s lack of a strong partisan orientation, however, should not be taken as a final judgment of either party. Rather, it represents an opportunity for both parties.
America’s youngest politically active cohort is upset with the status quo. But it votes for whichever party adopts moderate positions, and whichever party adopts a pluralist path forward has a chance to win Gen Z’s support.
The Democrats did that in 2022 on a host of salient political positions, but Democrats cannot afford to move too far from the center and adopt ultra-progressive positions that will prevent coalition building with many Americans. Republicans need to move on from Trump’s big lie about the 2020 election, defense of the Jan. 6 insurrection and other fringe positions.