Murphy’s ‘Hollywood’ a woke ’40s fantasy By Lynn Elber

Series tempers real-life tragedies

Ryan Murphy has a clear-eyed fascination with the 20th-century Hollywood dream machine, so adroit at making stars and breaking the hearts of those who didn’t fit the mold. Among the casualties: Anna May Wong and Hattie McDaniel, gifted actresses of color consigned to play stereotypes, and closeted matinee idol Rock Hudson.

Their stories are part of “Hollywood,” Murphy’s seven-episode Netflix limited series debuting Friday, but the producer of “American Horror Story,” “9-1-1” and “Pose” refused to leave it at that. In his optimistic version of what could have been, a hidebound industry is challenged by bold actors, writers and others who fight to be in the picture.

The series tempers real-life tragedies, including sexual exploitation of men and women, with its fantasy of a late 1940s woke Hollywood. A deeply nostalgic veneer of Tinsel Town lore and name-checked Los Angeles landmarks — such as century-old industry hangout Musso & Frank Grill — prove the myth’s allure, even for realists like Murphy.

The project “became sort of a love letter to Hollywood and a celebration of the best Hollywood could be,” he said. “And I think its themes are so modern. Every year we have a conversation around awards time about representation, about why are more people not included, why is everything so straight and white? This has been going on for years and years and years.”

“My first day in Hollywood was in 1998, so I was right of the tail end of, ‘You can’t be gay and be out of the closet. You can’t have a black woman in a romantic part,’” Murphy said. “I remember personally having that fear of, ‘Oh, I can’t be myself because then I’ll never work.’”

That oppressive cloud never lifted for Hudson, who’s portrayed by Jake Picking in “Hollywood” as a victim of a rapacious agent and hard-line expectations. Locked into idealized versions of romance opposite Doris Day and other leading ladies, he agreed to a faux marriage to fend off rumors that, at the time, would have ended his career.

“Until the day he died, he lived in fear he was going to be outed and vilified for being gay. So while he did have a certain amount of (career) success, he was torn apart inside,” Murphy said.

Bias also hit people of color hard. McDaniel became the first black actress to win an Oscar, for her 1939 “Gone with the Wind” role as Mammy — a role that typified the subservient characters she routinely had to play. Wong was denied the chance to play a rare lead Asian character in 1937’s “The Good Earth” when it went instead to white star Luise Rainer, along with a best-actress Oscar.

Murphy said he’s realized that “what I was really drawn to was the story of lost potential. Nothing in the world is sadder than that, to me.”

Characters

The fictional characters of “Hollywood” seek a happier ending. Among them: a studio boss’ slighted wife, played by Patti LuPone; an Asian American screenwriter (Darren Criss, also a series producer); a gay African American writer (Jeremy Pope) and a black actress with star power (Laura Harrier). The fictional characters rub shoulders with real-life figures including Hudson, Wong (Michelle Krusiec) and McDaniel (Queen Latifah). Jim Parsons, Dylan McDermott and David Corenswet also co-star.

Murphy also employs his knowledge of what he calls “buried history,” including a bustling LA service station that hired attractive young men to provide gas, and then some, for eager customers. Careful research went into the series’ re-creations of real events, period costumes and settings, Murphy said.

“The man is a huge fan of Hollywood, so it’s not surprising to me that this series was a passion project,” said Janet Mock, an executive producer, writer and director for the series who also works on “Pose” with Murphy. “He has a bold vision, and a part of that vision was to create a revisionist history of sorts that forces us to face our past while also thinking about how that has affected our present.”

There’s still work to be done to foster inclusiveness, said both Mock and Pope, a Broadway performer (“Ain’t Too Proud to Beg”) making his TV debut as screenwriter Archie.

“We have taken some steps and things have changed. We have evolved as an industry,” Pope said. But Murphy’s alternative Hollywood, “whether it’s set in the ’40s or in 2020, it begins to form how you think, and what’s possible.”

“Hollywood” follows a group of aspiring actors and filmmakers in post-World War II Hollywood as they try to make it in Tinseltown — no matter the cost. Each character offers a unique glimpse behind the gilded curtain of Hollywood’s Golden Age, spotlighting the unfair systems and biases across race, gender and sexuality that continue to this day . ... Hollywood exposes and examines decades-old power dynamics, and what the entertainment landscape might look like if they had been dismantled.

On February 23, 2019, it was announced that Netflix had given the production a straight-to-series order. The series was created by Ian Brennan, and Ryan Murphy. Brennan and Murphy were also set to executive produce the series alongside Darren Criss and David Corenswet. The series is set to be released on May 1, 2020.

On Rotten Tomatoes, the series holds an approval rating of 56% based on 36 reviews, with an average rating of 5.92/10. The site’s critical consensus reads: “With its heart on its sleeve and style to spare, Hollywood is anything but subtle—if only it’s good intentions were paired with a less convoluted story.” On Metacritic, the season has a weighted average score of 59 out of 100, based on 18 critics, indicating “mixed or average reviews”.

In an unfavorable review, Hugh Montgomery of the BBC described the series as “spineless and inert”.