What can be done about Washington diplomatic dumps?
The large building at the corner of 22nd and R streets in downtown Washington, DC, sticks out like a wart in the otherwise upscale neighborhood. Plywood covers the windows, sleeping bags and empty bottles litter the shuttered doorways and headhigh weeds sprout through the asphalt of the empty fenced-off parking lot. For a solid decade, neighbors and local political leaders complained bitterly about the condition of the former Pakistani consulate. But the city remained powerless to do anything as long as the building was classified by the State Department as a diplomatic property.
That diplomatic designation has since been revoked, according to the State Department, but the building still stands as perhaps the most egregious example of an only-in-DC phenomenon, where diplomatic protocol allows a string of abandoned buildings to fester, untouchable and taxfree. “Residents, who themselves are under obligation to keep their properties in order, are complaining to me,” said City Councilwoman Mary Cheh, whose Ward 3 contains several such problematic properties. “Unless the State Department is really committed to the issue, these countries can really string you along.”
Cheh’s office has compiled a partial list of vacant and neglected diplomatic buildings and she co-authored a bill calling for creating a comprehensive citywide list. Violators on Cheh’s list include properties owned by the governments of Serbia, Sri Lanka, Cameroon and Argentina.
Many of these eyesores are in some of the District’s most high-end neighborhoods. The Sheridan-Kalorama area, where several are located, is home to former President Barack Obama, as well as President Donald Trump’s daughter, Ivanka Trump and son-in-law Jared Kushner. Jeff Bezos, owner of Amazon and The Washington Post, recently bought a massive house there. The area’s most recent prominent resident is Secretary Of State Rex Tillerson, whose department is responsible for making sure these diplomatic properties are maintained.
The issue is particularly frustrating for members of the city council, who find themselves unable to use the many instruments at their disposal for dealing with neglected buildings. For example, the city has a three-tiered tax structure designed to compel landlords to maintain their properties. Ordinary buildings are taxed at 85 cents per $100 in assessed value; for a vacant property, that rate increases to $5 per $100 and if a property is judged by the city to be neglected or “blighted” the tax rate jumps to $10 per $100 in assessed value.
But that isn’t applicable for a diplomatic building. “If I have a vacant house in the Shaw neighborhood that’s becoming a problem, I can call in the cops, clean it up, throw a fence around it and if necessary seize it for unpaid taxes,” said City Councilman Jack Evans. “I have a lot of tools in my tool box. But I don’t have those tools available to me if it’s a diplomatic property.”
The State Department doesn’t have a lot of options either. Cliff Seagroves, acting head of the Office of Foreign Missions, said he’s largely bound by the 1961 Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations. Revoking a property’s diplomatic status is an extreme step that could provoke a diplomatic crisis and retaliatory action against US properties abroad. “We have to balance (local residents’ concerns) with making sure we’re not making things harder for ourselves overseas,” Seagroves said.
With limited options, Seagroves admitted that his office is often pleased to see negative press coverage of the issue that he hopes will embarrass intransigent nations into action. “The shame factor is often our most effective tool in getting these matters resolved,” he said. The case of the former Pakistani consulate on R Street stands as a rare recent success. But it’s also an example of how bad a situation has to get before the State Department will act. Seagroves said the Pakistani Foreign Ministry built a new embassy, moved its consular staff there and “in effect, walked away” from the old building.
After years of nagging, and with the building becoming a magnet for squatters, Seagroves’ office finally delivered an ultimatum and a deadline. When that passed, State revoked the diplomatic status in February 2016 and let the city move in and treat the property like any other blighted building. By June 2017, the property had accumulated more than $70,000 in tax debt. That debt was purchased by an investment group at a tax auction in July 2017, giving the Pakistani government about six months to settle the debt or risk losing the property.
The Pakistani government, in a statement to AP, said that “a plan is being worked out” for the building’s renovation and it was working with the State Department and District of Columbia government “to amicably resolve the issue”. However the Pakistani statement also pointed out that all diplomatic properties are exempt from taxation, a contention that seemingly ignores the revocation of the property’s diplomatic status.
Repeated queries as to the why the building fell into such an extreme state of disrepair went unanswered. While residents can claim victory there, the fight continues. One block away, down R Street, the former Serbian embassy sits in similar disrepair with its diplomatic status intact. Some of these unused buildings are unused for an understandable reason. —AP