Fact-checking ‘The Crown’: Did Britain want Elizabeth to abdicate to Charles?
IN the opening minutes of the new season of Netflix’s “The Crown,” we learn about a poll of the British public suggesting half of them think Queen Elizabeth II should abdicate in favor of Prince Charles.
An aide tells Charles, played by Dominic West, that the poll will come out while Charles is on vacation in Italy with his wife and sons, which the aide is encouraging the press to call a “second honeymoon.”
Later, royal aides try in vain to hide copies of the Sunday Times from Queen Elizabeth II.
So did that really happen? Did the public really want the queen to abdicate? And was there really a “second honeymoon” to Italy?
There really was a Sunday Times poll with the abdication question, but most of the details have been changed, no doubt to add Hollywood drama.
The poll came out in January 1990, not August 1991 as it does in the show, and nearly half said the queen should consider abdicating in favor of Charles. But, importantly, they said she should consider “eventually,” not necessarily at that very moment. The “eventually” has been left out in the show.
Other things left out: The real poll was largely positive about the royal family – only 6 per cent thought abolishing the monarchy would leave Britain better off – and support for Queen Elizabeth II and her mother was through the roof: Nine in 10 felt favorably or very favorably about them.
And there have been additions to add even more drama. In one scene, Charles appears to read from the article:
“An aging monarch, too long on the throne, whose remoteness from the modern world has led people to grow tired not just of her but of the monarchy itself.”
This is a made-up line that did not appear in the original, which the Sunday Times republished in September. Neither does the term “Queen Victoria Syndrome,” or that the public thought the queen was “old,” “irrelevant” or “out of touch.”
In another scene, Charles arranges a meeting with Prime Minister John Major, played by Jonny Lee Miller, and, buoyed by the poll, delicately pressures Major to encourage the queen to step down. Major, now 79, said recently a meeting like this never happened, calling it “a barrel-load of nonsense” and prompting reminders from the show’s creators that “The Crown” is a fictionalized version of real events - emphasis on the fictionalized.
The date of the poll’s release appears to have been moved in the show so that it would coincide with Charles and Diana’s vacation to Italy - a real trip they took in August 1991.
Coming a few weeks after the couple’s 10th wedding anniversary, some in the press really did dub it a “second honeymoon” at the time, though the show’s suggestion that this framing came from Charles’s camp appears to be artistic license.