The Star Malaysia - Star2

Watching and waiting

With elections in Malaysia drawing close, the classic graphic novel Watchmen offers some thoughts in government and power.

- By SHARMILLA GANESAN star2@thestar.com.my

THESE are certainly interestin­g times in Malaysia. With the 14th general elections only days away, almost every conversati­on – online, offline and everything in between – seems to be about politics.

These conversati­ons are necessary, and no doubt very important. But they can also become overwhelmi­ng, particular­ly when they cross the line into being less about the collective good and more about party loyalties.

At times like these, I’ve often found it helpful to mirror real life with something fictional, and for the last week or so, that mirror has been the seminal 1987 graphic novel Watchmen. Created by writer Alan Moore, artist Dave Gibbons and colourist John Higgins, Watchmen is often hailed as one of the most important literary works of the 20th century – not only is it considered the first comic book to be taken seriously by mainstream literary critics, it is the only graphic novel to be included in the 1001 Books You Must Read Before You Die (a situation which, in my opinion, needs correcting – but that’s a conversati­on for another day).

Watchmen’s critical and commercial success can be attributed to its incredibly layered storyline, which seems to yield something new with each read. Gibbons complement­s Moore’s plot with panels packed with details, with several stories and timelines linked through clever visual clues.

But what makes it such a relevant read for me now is its social and political commentary, from which there is much that can be drawn to parallel our current concerns. Watchmen is set in an alternate version of 1980s United States, where the existence of costumed crimefight­ers has changed the course of the country’s historical developmen­t.

While only one of these heroes actually has superpower­s – Dr Manhattan, due to a nuclear accident in a lab – these vigilantes grow to the capture the public’s imaginatio­n. Moore’s heroes, though are not paragons of virtue by any means. Instead, they are all flawed in some way or another – in other words, they are much like “ordinary” folks.

At the point when the novel begins superheroe­s have been outlawed, and most have retired. But when a former masked hero ends up dead, questions arise amongst the others about whether someone might be targeting them.

Watchmen deals with many difficult questions in relation to power, government and those we place in those positions. One of the core questions, however, is a simple one: who is to be held accountabl­e? This question is embodied by the phrase that pops up in various forms throughout the graphic novel: “Who watches the Watchmen?”

It is a question that has stuck with me as I think about the current state of our politics, which seem to be in many ways degenerati­ng into cults of personalit­y and blind party loyalty. Many of those advocating for change are sincere and reliable; the level of discourse among followers on both sides, however, can often seem indistingu­ishable from each other.

How can we advocate for or expect real change when both sides of the divide behave in the same petty and small-minded ways? When there seems to be much less talk about accountabi­lity or honesty, and instead, much more chest-thumping and name-calling?

So who does watch the Watchmen, those we’ve ostensibly entrusted to govern us? The simple answer is, it should be us. We should be holding all of them accountabl­e, not just the ones we oppose. The leaders we stand behind are as much a reflection of us as they are of their parties. Perhaps we should hold them, and ourselves, to a higher standard. Sharmilla Ganesan is currently reading her way through the titles in 1001 Books You Must Read Before You Die. Join the conversati­on at facebook. com/BeBookedOu­t or Tweet @ SharmillaG.

 ??  ?? Booked Out star2@thestar.com.my Sharmilla Ganesan
Booked Out star2@thestar.com.my Sharmilla Ganesan

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Malaysia