Why not a hybrid meeting?
THE Malaysian Bar is deeply disappointed by the recent news that today’s sitting of the Dewan Rakyat has been postponed indefinitely due to a number of Covid-19 cases detected in Parliament on July 29.
While the Malaysian Bar is cognisant of the perils of Covid-19, a question that has to be asked is why hybrid (ie, a mix of physically and virtually present MPS) Parliamentary meetings were not agreed to and voted on in the first place. The Speaker of the Dewan Rakyat had stated on July 25 – just one day before Parliament was scheduled to meet – that the proposal to conduct a hybrid session had been deferred, and that this matter would not be discussed during the special five-day sitting of the Dewan Rakyat. Pursuant to this decision, there was no limit placed on the number of Members of Parliament allowed in, and all elected representatives, even those who had not been vaccinated, were permitted to attend.
In light of the Covid-19 infections identified, the failure of Parliament to introduce a motion on hybrid measures, as well as to adopt them, means that Parliament meetings would continue to be postponed and, as a result, this is a hindrance to democracy.
Parliament could have employed hybrid mechanisms and appropriate SOPS early on to ensure the health of all those present during the meetings, as well as that of Parliament support staff. Such alternative arrangements are important during a time when the number of Covid-19 cases in our country has been rising exponentially. Our current Parliament is well equipped with the requisite technological tools to innovate and adapt to the current circumstances.
The Malaysian Bar considers the deferment of the discussion on hybrid meetings of Parliament a missed opportunity. This should have been addressed right at the beginning. The necessity for such an implementation is beyond peradventure, evident, and should have been a priority during a global pandemic.
We take the view that the postponement of the Dewan Rakyat meeting on Monday reflects negatively on those in positions of power. This is especially so when there are matters of significant national importance that need to be deliberated upon without further delay.
The rakyat are bearing the brunt of the social dislocation and economic disruption caused by the pandemic. The Malaysian Bar therefore calls on Parliament to convene without any further disruption or delay with strict SOPS in place. It should amend its standing orders to authorise hybrid Parliamentary meetings and thereafter immediately proceed with such a session.
Good governance must prevail during these unprecedented times to avert a Constitutional crisis, where the only ones who will suffer are the people of Malaysia.
AG KALIDAS President, Malaysian Bar