The Malta Independent on Sunday

It looks as though Europe has given itself another dictator to deal with

The situation in Turkey is now far worse than anybody could have foreseen, and this just a week after the failed coup d’état.

-

Though I do not concur with the widely touted notion that President Erdogan somehow incited or encouraged the failed attempt at deposing him so as to have justificat­ion for a widespread purge of his real and perceived enemies, he has used it for just that end. “He was prepared with lists and who to get rid of,” the conspiracy theorists say, “therefore he must have known about it in advance.” Not so – paranoid dictators always have lists of enemies of the state (we needn’t go far in time and place to work that out), and given the right setting, they will go wild with that.

The European Union’s latest threats that Turkey, a candidate country, will no longer be considered for membership unless it ceases immediatel­y with widespread violations of human rights and punishment without due process, and the reintroduc­tion of the death penalty, have had no effect. They seem, on the other hand, to have incited Erdogan to further acts of violence and intimidati­on against his own people. The EU Council of (Foreign) Ministers tells him to stop immediatel­y or forget EU membership forever, and he goes on ever greater rampages. The message here is that he doesn’t care a jot for EU membership, that somewhere along the line he stopped trying to have Turkey join or that he never wanted Turkey to be part of the process in the first place, but for some reason thought it fit to pretend. Or perhaps, as he and his sons accumulate­d not millions but billions through corruption and trading in influence, the realisatio­n dawned that, personally, they were far better off in a situation of ‘elected’ dictatorsh­ip, in full control of a country that is a democracy only in name, stuffing their private bank accounts like Pharaoh’s tomb (that’s something else that has echoes here in Malta, though of course on a much smaller scale because it’s a much smaller country, and it’s also in the European Union).

This past week it became quite clear that the European Union has lost its influence paranoia which afflicts, in the end, all real or would-be dictators. But Turkey’s membership was always so contentiou­s among the people of the European Union that the leaders of EU government­s were in no particular haste to hurry the Turkish government along in changing its laws and its attitudes to make the country EUready. And now look at what’s happened.

Yesterday, it got worse, much worse. Erdogan personally ordered the closure of thousands – yes, the scale of it is difficult for us to imagine – of private schools, charities and other institutio­ns. He was able to do this because the country is in a state of emergency which he himself has decreed. This gives him, literally, the powers of a dictator. The schools have been shut down because the clearly paranoid Erdogan suspects them of being loyal to the man he sees as his nemesis: Fethullah Gulen, who has lived quietly in the United States for several years. Erdogan says that Gulen was responsibl­e for the coup against him. Gulen has said it is just so much madness.

Erdogan’s wide-ranging order yesterday also banned 19 trade unions, shut down 15 universiti­es and 35 medical institutes. Technicall­y, Parliament must approve the decree but that has been treated as a mere formality to be dispensed with: the government (Erdogan’s party) has the simple majority required for that.

Instead of speaking for calm and order, Erdogan has continued to encourage his supporters out onto the streets, which has added to the instabilit­y Turkey now faces and to the intimidati­on of ordinary people who are scared to make their critical views known. More rallies have been held over this weekend in major towns and cities. In Istanbul, people are allowed free travel on the metro to get to the rallies. While they are on the trains, videos play on the advertisin­g and informatio­n screens, showing pictures of “martyrs” killed in the postcoup violence. Of course, these martyrs are Erdogan supporters.

And Turkey’s Minister for Eu-

 ??  ??

Newspapers in English

Newspapers from Malta